Well our bill was around $1250 for 25 tons of lime spread (not sure, they don't trust me to handle any money) and we bought 4 tons of fertilizer for almost $2k (spread). Total bill should have been in the zip code of $3500. We got twice as much spread as you did. We spent about 2.5x as much total so maybe that explains why some of it was cheaper. It's the 4th time we've used them. I'm also a very nice guy to deal with. That CAN'T have hurt. lol