I'm not so sure we aren't doing both now. Lots of clubs promote killing "mature deer" only, while other clubs go state game law only.

I've said it before that I'd rather see a spike killed versus a 6 point. 6 point is only a year or 2 away. Spike is 3.5 years away. Lot's of folks don't see it that way, but it's MY personal opinion. Oh, and I don't remember the last time I killed a spike or a 6 point.