Originally Posted by NightHunter
Originally Posted by centralala
But it has never wiped out a herd, correct?? It has been discussed to lengths about the disease itself and it's affect on a single deer. What has been seen on the affects on the WHOLE herd, how large of an area, and the herd 5-10 years later??



It seems a little different everywhere. No state has seen it act in the exact same way. A few states are beginning to see 30-50% prevalence rates in bucks 2.5+ and 30+% in the antlerless population. This has taken those states several years to get there. AR on the other hand has not been positive all that long and have seen prevalence rates cross the 20% mark already.

The population concern comes in at those 30% plus numbers. That is typically the percent we as hunters remove from the population. It obviously varies all over but that's kinda the rule of thumb, that with a healthy herd you'll hover around a 30% surplus. When you no longer have a surplus on the landscape and you continue to add up all of the different mortalities plus hunting related mortalities, you start driving your deer herd into lower and lower numbers.

That said, these states that have reached this mark have just started seeing this so we don't have a great grasp on what's going to happen. They are watching it and the results will be interesting to follow.



30% we take as hunters?? I've never heard that estimation. What about the % of other mortalities on average PER YEAR? In CWD areas, what is a estimation on mortality due to CWD ON AVERAGE per YEAR? Given those 3 %s for a total death rate ESTIMATION PER YEAR, then you will be putting out something the average hunter can understand.

I had a class once where the professor was so knowledgeable on the subject, what was basic to him was over the heads of the students. Y'all need to remember that. No way the average Alabama hunter knows what a prion is or will take the time to learn. BASIC, BASIC, BASIC!! Numbers, whether factual, estimation, or for illustration purpose are good as long as they are clearly labeled for intended purpose.