I have hunted both and gravitated to hunting only Wheeler. If you do your homework, you can find some really good spots that nobody else hunts, or seldom hunts. After gun season starts, it is much easier to find areas that receive little to no pressure. I have stopped hunting there since I joined a club. My son hunts there some and seems like some of my honey holes are now a little more popular than when I hunted them.

I always felt that Skyline had bigger deer but Wheeler has some big deer also. I never liked the thought of 10,000 people coming in on a weekend and shooting everything up, plus I normally hunted alone and the thought of dragging a deer up the side of a mountain (which I've done) is not very appealing to me.