|
1
|
2
|
3
|
4
|
5
|
6
|
7
|
8
|
9
|
10
|
11
|
12
|
13
|
14
|
15
|
16
|
17
|
18
|
19
|
20
|
21
|
22
|
23
|
24
|
25
|
26
|
27
|
28
|
29
|
30
|
|
|
|
|
|
72 registered members (mossyback, Bread, Ray_Coon, eclipse829, BigA47, deadeye48, BuckRidge17, BhamFred, hunterturf, 7x57_Mauser, Peach, Mbrock, MoeBuck, Drycreek, globe, catdoctor, Holcomb, DoubleShoalsJR, Kemosabe, Mmiller, Tree Dweller, SurveyinAL, 7PTSPREAD, BC_Reb, AustinC, TEM, misfire, Jdkprp70, Aldecks1, imadeerhntr, BOFF, AU7MM08, CrimsonWSM, Flyliner, sj22, CrappieMan, doghouse, MarksOutdoors, bambam32, Joe4majors, Jweeks, BrandonClark, Irishguy, Hoytdad10, sidehitter, Dubie, SouthBamaSlayer, PourIron12, outdoorguy88, dirtwrk, Backwards cowboy, Cactus_buck, Jay512, Rolloverdave, Hunting-231, Justice, gman, Reaper, Solothurn, 2walnuts, Kang, curt99rsv, booner, Gut Pile 32, 8 invisible),
1,085
guests, and 0
spiders. |
Key:
Admin,
Global Mod,
Mod
|
|
|
Brush guns.
#3071365
03/18/20 10:41 PM
03/18/20 10:41 PM
|
Joined: Dec 2012
Posts: 9,643 Pisgah Al
Bigbamaboy
OP
14 point
|
OP
14 point
Joined: Dec 2012
Posts: 9,643
Pisgah Al
|
Here goes... I’m already tired of talking about the Chinese virus and as of late, brush guns have piqued my interest. So, I hope this turns into a long discussion.
1) do y’all think there is even such thing as a brush gun... as in an actual round that’s capable of push light brush and twigs out of the way without deflection? This part doesn’t debate the fact that there are several carbine rifles that are easier to wield in the woods. That’s a given. I’m just asking about the round.
2) if you answered yes to 1, what would that round (your personal favorite) be?
3) I like the looks of the Ruger American 450 BM, possibly the Henry Single 45-70 or the most likely candidate, a CVA Scout in 44 mag.
4) I’m particularly interested in the 44 mag bc I already have a SW629 and lots of 44 brass, plus I’ve got a screw in my shoulder and the heavy recoil isn’t my thing.
5) what’s the real world capability of a 240-300 gr 44 mag round in a carbine length barrel?
6) I’ve got a 270 I’ve been shooting since I was 15. Should I just save my money on a new rifle and buy powder and .277 bullets?
Eli, Eli, lama sabachthani?
|
|
|
Re: Brush guns.
[Re: Bigbamaboy]
#3071405
03/18/20 11:31 PM
03/18/20 11:31 PM
|
Joined: Jul 2014
Posts: 5,511 sellers, montgomery county
paulfish4570
12 point
|
12 point
Joined: Jul 2014
Posts: 5,511
sellers, montgomery county
|
ALL bullets, no matter weight or speed, can be thrown off target by the smallest of twigs. study after study has proven this. my own experience has proven it with unseen twigs. one example: 240-grain .44 magnum bullet thrown off 18 inches at less than 15 yards. do NOT shoot through brush ...
Last edited by paulfish4570; 03/18/20 11:31 PM.
paulfish4570 Joshua 1:9
|
|
|
Re: Brush guns.
[Re: Bigbamaboy]
#3071428
03/19/20 04:36 AM
03/19/20 04:36 AM
|
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 12,703 behind my Dillon
dave260rem!
Skinny’s Ex
|
Skinny’s Ex
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 12,703
behind my Dillon
|
I'll chime in on #5. The 300 grain .44's will not disappoint true you can't drive them like a 240 but the weight helps out. Range?125 yards is all I'd try.y
Only hits count.
|
|
|
Re: Brush guns.
[Re: Bigbamaboy]
#3071444
03/19/20 05:53 AM
03/19/20 05:53 AM
|
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 44,211 North Alabama
Wiley Coyote
Freak of Nature
|
Freak of Nature
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 44,211
North Alabama
|
Save your money and start loading.
I firmly believe that a double gallows should be constructed on the East Lawn of The White House. Politicians who willfully and shamelessly violate their oath to uphold and defend the Constitution of the United States of America should be swiftly tried and, upon conviction, publicly hanged at sunup the day after conviction. If multiple convicts are to be hanged they can choose with whom to share the gallows or names shall be drawn from the hangman's hat to be hanged 2 at a time.
NRA Life Member
|
|
|
Re: Brush guns.
[Re: Bigbamaboy]
#3071470
03/19/20 06:52 AM
03/19/20 06:52 AM
|
Joined: Mar 2018
Posts: 16,827 Banana Republic
jb20
Old Mossy Horns
|
Old Mossy Horns
Joined: Mar 2018
Posts: 16,827
Banana Republic
|
My dad gave me a saftey lesson when I was 7yr old before goin hunting one time. He had a marlin 44mag that was the closest thing for my fit. He walked up to a pine tree about the size of a wrist and said cover your ears, then blew a hole thru it, looked at me n said be careful with this gun ☺
They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety. Ben Franklin
|
|
|
Re: Brush guns.
[Re: paulfish4570]
#3071514
03/19/20 08:07 AM
03/19/20 08:07 AM
|
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 3,294 Autaugaville
trailertrash
10 point
|
10 point
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 3,294
Autaugaville
|
ALL bullets, no matter weight or speed, can be thrown off target by the smallest of twigs. study after study has proven this. my own experience has proven it with unseen twigs. one example: 240-grain .44 magnum bullet thrown off 18 inches at less than 15 yards. do NOT shoot through brush ... Agreed, the article I read years ago actually suggested (after testing) a smaller caliber bullet as it was less likely to strike something than a big bore but in the end they said just don't do it unless you have to such as a wounded game type scenerio. There was something about buckshot in the article also. Seems the spherical projectiles did well (relative to bullets). The testing was done by toothpicks stuck in a block of wood and then fired through at a target. The toothpicks and target ranges varied. It was interesting enough for me to remember it a dozen years later but I have lost the details to time.
Last edited by trailertrash; 03/19/20 08:10 AM.
"We aren't here to justify your feelings and give you self worth" - Aldeer Welcome Center
|
|
|
Re: Brush guns.
[Re: Bigbamaboy]
#3071540
03/19/20 08:28 AM
03/19/20 08:28 AM
|
Joined: Feb 2019
Posts: 3,918 Montgomery,al,usa
Davyalabama
10 point
|
10 point
Joined: Feb 2019
Posts: 3,918
Montgomery,al,usa
|
I'm not sure there is a brush gun in-so-far as rifles go --- #1 buckshot always did pretty well when we ran dogs years ago (don't flame me, that is how I was brought up and we had plenty of good fellowship, although I did get a shirt-tail trimmed a couple times). If you haven't had your shirt-tailed trimmed, well you're just better than me.
If you like that 30-30, why not just buy a used one and carry it?
“If you do not conquer self, you will be conquered by self.” Napoleon Hill The most difficult thing to understand during conversation is silence. Thoreau
|
|
|
Re: Brush guns.
[Re: Bigbamaboy]
#3071553
03/19/20 08:50 AM
03/19/20 08:50 AM
|
Joined: Sep 2012
Posts: 18,048 North AL
AU338MAG
Old Mossy Horns
|
Old Mossy Horns
Joined: Sep 2012
Posts: 18,048
North AL
|
In reality, there is no such thing as a brush gun for whitetail hunting. That said, some guns with certain bullets will track straighter through brush than others, but a 570 Nitro Express is not a good choice in the woods of Alabama. The recoil is a little stout and could rock you outta your tree. 😀
Dying ain't much of a living boy...Josey Wales
Molon Labe
|
|
|
Re: Brush guns.
[Re: Bigbamaboy]
#3071563
03/19/20 08:59 AM
03/19/20 08:59 AM
|
Joined: May 2018
Posts: 2,854 Banks of Little River
JohnnyLoco
10 point
|
10 point
Joined: May 2018
Posts: 2,854
Banks of Little River
|
I’ll stick to common calibers on this subject, three of note in order of effectiveness in my observation. My observations also extend to hunting outside of Alabama in some brush that is extremely stout. Please note that I always try to take a clear shot but sometimes that picture doesn’t play out the way it looked in the scope. My personal experience shows very little deflection, just tears the limbs up. I think there are many variables, but I do believe in a true “brush gun”. I find a shotgun in theory a candidate but in action...Nope.
The 35 Whelen 444 Marlin 45/70
I have a relative that uses a 35 Whelen for primitive season, if y’all could see the size tree the bullet went through and still killed the buck, you’d agree its #1
I use a 444 and I’m always astounded. I also use 44 Mag with great results.
The 45/70 with hotter velocity works in brush but its tree puncturing is hindered by the diameter of the 45 cal
Last edited by JohnnyLoco; 03/19/20 09:08 AM.
|
|
|
Re: Brush guns.
[Re: Bigbamaboy]
#3071654
03/19/20 09:57 AM
03/19/20 09:57 AM
|
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 9,166 B'ham
Goatkiller
14 point
|
14 point
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 9,166
B'ham
|
I was going to jump in and say the same as GKelly. A "Brush Gun" to me might just mean the same as a "Treestand Gun" would to someone else.
It is a short barrel carbine. Because it is a short barrel carbine it is not meant to shoot long distances, therefore there is no need for a long range cartridge. If there is no need for a long range cartridge then you may as well shoot something that hits hard.
To some that is a 44 Magnum Ruger Carbine (Alabama) 50-100yds in a pine thicket.. To others that is the carbine version of a .35 Whelen Rem 760 Pump (Alaska) maybe up to 200 yards or just over.
To me the best of these is in a caliber that can still shoot some resonable distance.
.358 Winchester is the best to me because it is short action vs .35 Whelen. But very comparable. Same bullet at nearly same velocity.
I do love a .45/70 but the bullet selection is lacking for mid range distances vs. the .35's bullets which are much better suited for it.
The .35's are some badass rounds. They hit hard and there is no need for fancy bonded bullets (and all that debatable BS) when you are shooting a 200 or 200+ grain chunk of lead.
No government employees were harmed in the making of this mess.
|
|
|
Re: Brush guns.
[Re: ValleyDawg]
#3071963
03/19/20 03:19 PM
03/19/20 03:19 PM
|
Joined: Dec 2012
Posts: 9,643 Pisgah Al
Bigbamaboy
OP
14 point
|
OP
14 point
Joined: Dec 2012
Posts: 9,643
Pisgah Al
|
There is a really good video on YouTube about this by an account called iraqveteran8888 or something along those lines. I think it is 2 videos actually. What he found is that while all bullets will have deflection, some deflected much less than others and stayed on target. It also really boiled down to the bullet as well. The flat and round nose bullets tended to deflect less than the pointed bullets. The 45-70 did really good but I think the best one in his test was 30-06 with 220gr round nose bullets. I stick with a 405 or 350gr flat nose 45-70 or a 30-30 for the majority of my hunting. All thick woods right now. Watched it. I like his videos.
Eli, Eli, lama sabachthani?
|
|
|
Re: Brush guns.
[Re: Bigbamaboy]
#3078332
03/24/20 01:59 PM
03/24/20 01:59 PM
|
Joined: May 2018
Posts: 2,854 Banks of Little River
JohnnyLoco
10 point
|
10 point
Joined: May 2018
Posts: 2,854
Banks of Little River
|
Nope, all bullets don’t deflect in brush.
I view it as a carbine type gun capable of fast follow ups in a sufficient caliber for the purpose. A Rem 742 18” Carbine in 30-06 with the 220 grain would probably fit the profile too.
Last edited by JohnnyLoco; 03/24/20 02:01 PM.
|
|
|
Re: Brush guns.
[Re: Bigbamaboy]
#3078769
03/24/20 06:33 PM
03/24/20 06:33 PM
|
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 36,183 alabama
BhamFred
Freak of Nature
|
Freak of Nature
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 36,183
alabama
|
I shot a Rem 742 30/06 with a 16 1/2" bbl, BIG peep sight and 180gr Corelocts, deadly clearcut gun.
I've spent most of the money I've made in my lifetime on hunting and fishing. The rest I just wasted.....
proud Cracker-Americaan
muslims are like coyotes, only good one is a dead one
|
|
|
Re: Brush guns.
[Re: JohnnyLoco]
#3079049
03/24/20 09:11 PM
03/24/20 09:11 PM
|
Joined: Jan 2018
Posts: 4,130 GA
UncleHuck
10 point
|
10 point
Joined: Jan 2018
Posts: 4,130
GA
|
Nope, all bullets don’t deflect in brush.
I view it as a carbine type gun capable of fast follow ups in a sufficient caliber for the purpose. A Rem 742 18” Carbine in 30-06 with the 220 grain would probably fit the profile too. While I will agree that for some reason, all bullets don't, but all bullets CAN. The excellent pic of the beech tree that got hit dead center, then killed a deer, could have been much different if the bullet had hit the side of that tree. The truth is, ALL bullets CAN deflect, and no human can predict when they will or won't. Therefore, it is highly irresponsible to take a shot through brush.
|
|
|
Re: Brush guns.
[Re: hawndog]
#3079062
03/24/20 09:22 PM
03/24/20 09:22 PM
|
Joined: Apr 2013
Posts: 4,619 Alabama
Rmart30
10 point
|
10 point
Joined: Apr 2013
Posts: 4,619
Alabama
|
All bullets will deflect shooting through brush. "brush gun" is a term that needs to be retired. Light weight short barreled guns are nice for short range, quick shots, and moving targets. But you still need a clear shot. Agreed. My close range thumper is a CVA 35 Remington.
Ethical behavior is doing the right thing when no one else is watching - even when doing the wrong thing is legal. Aldo Leopold .. (except when it comes to trailer tags)
|
|
|
Re: Brush guns.
[Re: UncleHuck]
#3079362
03/25/20 09:11 AM
03/25/20 09:11 AM
|
Joined: Dec 2012
Posts: 9,643 Pisgah Al
Bigbamaboy
OP
14 point
|
OP
14 point
Joined: Dec 2012
Posts: 9,643
Pisgah Al
|
Nope, all bullets don’t deflect in brush.
I view it as a carbine type gun capable of fast follow ups in a sufficient caliber for the purpose. A Rem 742 18” Carbine in 30-06 with the 220 grain would probably fit the profile too. While I will agree that for some reason, all bullets don't, but all bullets CAN. The excellent pic of the beech tree that got hit dead center, then killed a deer, could have been much different if the bullet had hit the side of that tree. The truth is, ALL bullets CAN deflect, and no human can predict when they will or won't. Therefore, it is highly irresponsible to take a shot through brush. My intent isn’t to go around shooting into brush. My intent is to mitigate the chance that stray twig I didn’t see in the heat of the moment deflects me off a deer. This year is the first time I’ve shot at a deer in 6 years. I was ground hunting in thick cover with a 243. Deer was at 75 yards and I had a dead steady brace. I know I didn’t pull off the deer, but I never found hair or blood. I looked for about 2 hours but no success. There were a few thin, spaghetti size, vines that I noticed after the fact. I can’t help but wonder if one deflected that little 85gr TSX.
Eli, Eli, lama sabachthani?
|
|
|
Re: Brush guns.
[Re: Bull64]
#3079411
03/25/20 09:51 AM
03/25/20 09:51 AM
|
Joined: Dec 2012
Posts: 9,643 Pisgah Al
Bigbamaboy
OP
14 point
|
OP
14 point
Joined: Dec 2012
Posts: 9,643
Pisgah Al
|
.243Win and brush don’t mix... I agree. I carried it bc I was hunting the side of the mountain, and it’s the lightest, most compact rifle I had.
Eli, Eli, lama sabachthani?
|
|
|
Re: Brush guns.
[Re: Bigbamaboy]
#3079549
03/25/20 11:51 AM
03/25/20 11:51 AM
|
Joined: May 2018
Posts: 2,854 Banks of Little River
JohnnyLoco
10 point
|
10 point
Joined: May 2018
Posts: 2,854
Banks of Little River
|
I don’t intentionally shoot brush either. The quite many times I pound through some brush or skin a tree, its not at the location of game, rather very close to me where it didn’t show up in the scope.
Last edited by JohnnyLoco; 03/25/20 11:53 AM.
|
|
|
Re: Brush guns.
[Re: Bigbamaboy]
#3079553
03/25/20 11:54 AM
03/25/20 11:54 AM
|
Joined: Dec 2012
Posts: 9,643 Pisgah Al
Bigbamaboy
OP
14 point
|
OP
14 point
Joined: Dec 2012
Posts: 9,643
Pisgah Al
|
Yep. It’s also hard to get deer to stop in a perfect opening.
Eli, Eli, lama sabachthani?
|
|
|
Re: Brush guns.
[Re: Bigbamaboy]
#3085980
03/31/20 11:07 PM
03/31/20 11:07 PM
|
Joined: Dec 2013
Posts: 1,647 Hazel Green
Oscarflytyer
8 point
|
8 point
Joined: Dec 2013
Posts: 1,647
Hazel Green
|
1) do y’all think there is even such thing as a brush gun... as in an actual round that’s capable of push light brush and twigs out of the way without deflection?
LONG long time ago, an in-depth test PROVED that ANY bullet was deflected. Key was, a very light bullet (say 55 gr 223) was deflected a lot more than a big ol' fat (say, cast RN 405 gr 45-70) bullet. Bottom line - don't go trying to shoot deer thru trees. It is pure stupidity, and not ethical!
Having said THAT, for brush, there are a bunch (both OLD and new). Some I have that I consider brush calibers (more because close range game getters, and quick in lever and iron sight setups) are lever guns in 30-30, 32 WS, 35 Rem, 43 Spanish and 45-70. Olders in 38-55, 405, 348 Win, 33 WCF, etc. More gun/cal combo. Same with any of the Savage 99s in heavy calibers or slow rounds, like 30-30, 303, 358. Oh yeah, and BLR in 358 Win!!! A good bolt in 300 H&H/375 H&H/458 Win, with good peep sights (think Africa rifles) would be great too
|
|
|
Re: Brush guns.
[Re: Oscarflytyer]
#3086681
04/01/20 06:04 PM
04/01/20 06:04 PM
|
Joined: Jan 2018
Posts: 4,130 GA
UncleHuck
10 point
|
10 point
Joined: Jan 2018
Posts: 4,130
GA
|
1) do y’all think there is even such thing as a brush gun... as in an actual round that’s capable of push light brush and twigs out of the way without deflection?
LONG long time ago, an in-depth test PROVED that ANY bullet was deflected. Key was, a very light bullet (say 55 gr 223) was deflected a lot more than a big ol' fat (say, cast RN 405 gr 45-70) bullet. Bottom line - don't go trying to shoot deer thru trees. It is pure stupidity, and not ethical!
Having said THAT, for brush, there are a bunch (both OLD and new). Some I have that I consider brush calibers (more because close range game getters, and quick in lever and iron sight setups) are lever guns in 30-30, 32 WS, 35 Rem, 43 Spanish and 45-70. Olders in 38-55, 405, 348 Win, 33 WCF, etc. More gun/cal combo. Same with any of the Savage 99s in heavy calibers or slow rounds, like 30-30, 303, 358. Oh yeah, and BLR in 358 Win!!! A good bolt in 300 H&H/375 H&H/458 Win, with good peep sights (think Africa rifles) would be great too No. Not every shot will deflect, but every bullet that contacts anything other than air between you and the animal has the potential to deflect. For close hunting, it's hard to beat a short barrel .308.
|
|
|
Re: Brush guns.
[Re: Emuckfwa]
#3096121
04/11/20 07:10 AM
04/11/20 07:10 AM
|
Joined: Apr 2015
Posts: 472 La and fla panhandle
Floridajew
4 point
|
4 point
Joined: Apr 2015
Posts: 472
La and fla panhandle
|
Remington 7600 carbine 35 Whelen or Browning BLR 358 Winchester. Love 35 cal for up close and DRT Love my 7600 carbine shes mostly a safe queen these days never thought of it as a brush gun .
|
|
|
Re: Brush guns.
[Re: BPI]
#3096194
04/11/20 08:35 AM
04/11/20 08:35 AM
|
Joined: Oct 2017
Posts: 4,717 You are ignoring this user
Thread Killer
10 point
|
10 point
Joined: Oct 2017
Posts: 4,717
You are ignoring this user
|
I think the youtuber Iraqveteran88 ( best I can remember ) did an in depth trial on your standard brush gun calibers verses regular spitzer type calibers and the results were pretty cool. I didn't think there could be a difference but that video make a believer out of me. IV8888. Very good Pro 2A channel with lots of good info. Eric and Chad are good dudes. Barry "the old man" in their older videos would have fit in good here. RIP Barry.
|
|
|
Re: Brush guns.
[Re: Bigbamaboy]
#3098159
04/13/20 11:04 AM
04/13/20 11:04 AM
|
Joined: Dec 2014
Posts: 7,529 Boaz,AL
CarbonClimber1
14 point
|
14 point
Joined: Dec 2014
Posts: 7,529
Boaz,AL
|
I was a 100% brush huntin guide in texas and i waded and crawled through black brush,twisted accacia, and catclaw after a bunch of deer,hogs,an javelina. I carried a 357 model 27 smith with the hammer filed off and a tear away holster under my left arm. Before that i carried a lever gun chambered in 44 magnum. The lever gun was too long so i switched to the revolver. I only ever had to shoot a few..most got stabbed...but wounded animals are what they are...desperate...and theyll hurt you. Both would ahoot through brush an kill whayever was 10 or 15 feet past them...but i could usually pick a hole out. I wouldnt recommend you shoot through a whole lot of brush..but a heavy solid bullet will pole through some and still kill...ive dunnit...bunches.
"I dont quit.. And ill fight alone if i have to"
|
|
|
|