I have a pair of 8.5D
Redwing 877s.
They've had very little use. I normally wear an 8.5D street shoe and a 9D boot or sneaker, and these fit fine.
They're all leather with a vibram sole, although as you can see from the pictures in the link, they're not a lug sole - they're designed not to collect mud, but nevertheless have decent traction.
I particularly like the fact that all the lace points are round eyelets, with none of the metal hooks that can collect grass and debris.
I like them, but just don't wear them enough to keep them. I think I paid something close to the $300 MSRP, like maybe $285.
You can have them for $150 picked up in Bham or $175 shipped.
Can text you pics if you like.