Dead is dead. It dont matter one bit how you do it, whether its a coon, a man, a deer or a dog. Taking a life is just that it dont matter if its by syringe, pan full of golden malrin, 143gr ELDX, or a piece of chicken on a big treble hook. Its all the same, but it makes some people feel better about the way they do it if the point at tht other guys way and say hes doing it the cruel way. Results are 100% the same for the dead thing, its dead