Someone on here tell me this: how long would it take to completely ruin a couple prime properties, if the state was to acquire two 1500-2,500 acre tracts at Safford and Portland and then just put them into the general WMA pool with 7 day a week access and no shooting requirements other than state regs???
The truthful answer is that, even as prime as those two properties would be, with the pressure those two properties would receive, you wouldn’t be able to find a deer on them, much less kill one after the second week of gun season and that is the absolute truth. After a full deer season, they wouldn’t even be worth hunting the following year.
Unless it is massive tracts of land, People and access have to be controlled to some extent because when something is “free”, people are greedy by nature, and cannot control or limit themselves.
I used to regularly turkey hunt Boykin mgmt area, it was almost 18,000 acres and I cannot count the number of times I was working a bird and had multiple hunters rush in on me and the bird, even though they had to come right by my truck, and knew that someone was already in there. If access is not in some way limited by either quota draw or limited, first come first serve, limited number, daily issued permits, And closed days, the place is quickly ruined. I know what the deer hunting was like, and what was killed when it was in the WMA program and rest assured, the groups leasing that land, now that it is back in private hands, are killing bucks and seeing numbers of deer that were not ever seen or even there to be seen, when that land was open to public. It was shot to hell and back and any deer that was seen, was immediately put on the back of a truck or snuck out in a dog/tool box (does).
So you think we are better off now without Boykin or scotch? I agree there are probably better ways to manage wmas to cut down on the pressure/killing. I just don’t think we are better off letting them disappear in exchange for SOAs that we can enjoy a 4 day weekend on once every 5-10 years.
Dallas county has some land open to public access. It’s a small tract and bow only. Much less pressured than Barbour, cahaba, lowndes etc. is it as good as an SOA? No. But it’s available to be used and better than a lot of low end clubs. ……
Add up all the potential public land in Dallas county. Corp land, forever wild, Portland landing, and cedar creek. That’s 20k+ acres to spread our pressure. Would it be “ruined”? Maybe compared to if mossy oak had it. Could you put rules in place that allowed for reasonable public use while still maintaining some of its greatness? Absolutely!
imagine if the state took on adding small tracts for public use, at the rate they are adding SOAs….. in 10 years we would all have multiple opportunities within a reasonable drive. Pressure would be spread out. Most of the Midwest is like this. Drop a pin on the map and you likely have 5-10 tracts of land within a 30 minute drive. Plus, it’s a lot easier to find 4K acres than 30k.