I can't speak to the brand names but make sure what you get has a way to lock them in place. I speak from experience. Last year I had some good sturdy plastic ones that had creeped on the floorboard and the corner made it to the accelerator. After putting my foot down I inadvertently push the floor mat into the accelerator and my truck took off. Not knowing the cause at the moment I hit the brakes but the mat was still juicing the accelerator. Made for a bit of a scare as the vehicle stopped at the light in front of me was fast approaching. Got it slowed down enough to slam it into park and catch my breath. No harm and a valuable lesson learned that day.