it doesn't make any difference who shot any or all of the bucks. In a herd with too many deer for the lands carrying capacity and prolly skewered ratios...YOU STILL HAVE TOO MANY DOES. Too many deer, then you have too many does. IF you stop killing bucks for five years...you will still have too many does, in fact way too many does. So "too many does" can and does exist in overpopulated herds. Solution is to kill selected number of the too populated does and slow or stop buck killing. The total numbers still have to be kept in check with the habitat, natural and manmade.

I have hunted in Choctaw Co near Mt Sterling and seen 100 deer in a smallish greenfield with only 3-4 small bucks present. Everybody on the place would see the same thing. Too many deer/too many does.