I don't see how you guys had only 6 weeks to recover. My son did his playing football, and he did accelerated rehabbed at Andrews every day for months and it was 4 months before they released him to play baseball and he still wasn't anywhere near 100%.
When I tore mine I had surgery the first week of November and pitched our first game mid February. Think I went 4 innings. I wasn't 100% though and honestly probably pushed it too hard too soon, but it was my senior year.