Originally Posted by R_H_Clark
Originally Posted by Goatkiller
If it is in really good shape I would say between $5-600 in a private sale is reasonable. You'll just have to decide how much you want it. Consider the 1894 is about $600 new.

For example I wanted a Ruger 44 carbine.... I use to have one and sold it years ago. They are about $650-800+ on Gunbroker. That's what everyone on here said they were worth. Referenced Gun Broker as their source of info.

I could have purchased about 10 since that time (we'll say 2 years) for between $5-600.


A 44 would be worth more than a 30-30.


I would say a 336 is worth maybe $4-500 in the described condition that's what I see those going for. But that's just my opinion. I'm not going to show up with a train car load I bought for less than $500 just to prove a point.

No government employees were harmed in the making of this mess.