A lot of good ideas, but nothing that jumps out at me. The organization won't make it without a catchy name and slogan. I guess the idea dies here and hunting is just doomed.

Don't give up so easily PCP. Nobody has mentioned calling it Chuckie Checker's Worst Nightmare (CCWN) yet. Kill 'em all and watch 'em fall.

In my club in Jackson County, he has to be 8 point and have 16" inside spread or score 120". We hunt over 4,000 acres and their have only been 2 good bucks killed this season. There are numerous awesome hunters in the club, with these strict of rules shouldn't there be 10-15 130+ bucks hitting the ground each season? There isn't, I don't like the state telling me how many bucks I can kill in a season or any organization either. I only shoot good deer, last season I killed a mature 10 pt (13in wide), mature 4 point (14 in wide) and a goofed up 6 point that was 17 in wide. All of these were on private land so there were no regulations. But, all three wouldn't have made the club rules and they were all 4.5+ yrs old. They are all trophies in my book, the only rule that I approve of is a base mass measurment. I have seen plenty of young wide 8 pts, that rule is a good way to get your good genetic deer killed quick. I have never seen a young buck with big mass at the bases though. I hunt for fun, I spend thousands on this hobby every season. But regulation after regulation will drive this honest hunter away. My rule for people that hunt on my personal lease is "shoot what makes you happy!"

Let's say you have 5 people on 200 acres with 15" limit and 4 yr. or older bucks limit with 3 buck limit. You shoot the only 3 club limit bucks no one else shoots any, would they be happy? Your neighbor shoots the 2 to 3 yr. old bucks or those in the club take a few meat bucks you don't know about. How many bucks will you see next year you think in 4 yr. old category? Really, the club limits on numbers and size should vary yearly based on your deer populations not on what is state limits. Get the picture. Kind of makes it hard to keep members unless you have a good year to year deer population.