My pet peeves would be the obvious reenactment stuff.

The buck is supposedly standing out there at 40 yards and the camera cuts to a shot of the bow hunter talking rather loudly about the buck, pointing, and moving way too much to avoid spooking a mature buck only 40 yards away. Scenes like this are obviously filmed after the kill and edited in but WHY?

Then there is the even worse reenacted blood trail. I have actually seen them film the hunter supposedly following the blood trail and they ultimately pan back to reveal that the camera man is set up filming from beside where the deer is lying dead on the ground. Really? You would think the camera man would yell out and say, "Hey Jim you can stop blood trailing now I'm standing beside the deer over here. " LOL! I mean how stupid do they think people are.