Beg to differ. I have killed a number of bucks that I know came to a urine attractant. One in particular stands out, where I was using a drag rag behind my boot of Code Blue Doe Estrous and I had walked across a large field on my way to a back treeline. I saw the buck enter the field from some small planted pines over 600 yards from my stand. When he crossed my path, he immediately put his nose on the ground and started to trot towards me. I had placed a stick 30 yards from my stand and turned the bottle upside down and place it one the stick. He sprinted right to the stick and actually knocked it off to the ground. I arrowed him seconds later.

Another time, I had a big dominant buck that came in following Harmons Dominant Buck urine and walked directly to my tree.

It works sometimes and other times it has probably cost me a shot or two, but I will continue to take my chances with it.