Oil lightly.. too much oil will make it floppy and therefore make it harder to catch than a new glove. Light oil and break it in naturally.
X2. I really like the Shoeless Joe gloves. They come in ready to roll.
The Nokona gloves are soft and well made as well and don't require alot of break in time or oil to help soften it......
I call BS on that...They are well made, real leather, but the catchers mitts are hell to break in...Fielders gloves are easier to break in and last a long time