I've killed deer 5 years ago that I still remember down to the exact details, this guy couldn't even get the details straight within the week of the deer being shot. Lot of story changing. Some what of a red flag.

There's a lot of night hunting that goes on in and around the mines and strip pits around this area the deer was killed. I really don't know if it was illegal or not, but they claimed it was shot one afternoon and they went back to find it the next morning, sure looked like it was a fresh kill in one of the dark pics. The only other thing I have to add is some of his "friends" are pretty well known as night hunters in the area same ones that was vouching for him.

But who knows.