Without a doubt (IMO) the Muzzy will give you great cut-on-demand with manageable arrow effects. Now I am a fan of many broadheads, but I recently given the Rage a try and I am very impressed. They fly practically like a Field point with the end result looking like a 2" wide sword was used to slice a hole in the deer. You won't get as many pass throughs with a rage, but the entrance hole will bleed a deer out in no time.
A great resource to build your own opinion is YouTube. Look up broadhead comparisons and you'll see different broadheads used in some extreme ways to compare them.
