Aldeer.com Forums Alabama Deer Talk Serious Deer Talk Forum 140 inch buck

Mackdaddy where did you guide at?

Matt, me and you almost always on the same page, this post is same sentence, word for word! You nailed it! I hunt more than 10 days a year, but I stay outa big buck core areas, jumping around shooting does till the "time is right."

It ain't worth a dime to me. I have made it 32 years without one that big and the sun still came up the next day. It would be nice, but until I am blessed enough to shoot one, I will hunt my little spot in between 72 hour work weeks and just hope one comes through. I have let enough small deer go over the years, it will happen.

Me either. I wouldn't pay anything outside of the cost of a lease for a 200" deer.

There are several clubs in different parts of this state where it is possible to kill 130"+ deer every year.

Most people in this part of the world wouldn't know a 140 if it horned their leg, just sayin...

Everybody in this post talkin about all the 140 deer they have shot, and low and behold someone posts a pic of their 140 that might score 125 with some novice scorer... I've got 3 bucks you could set that buck almost inside, all have been officials scored, none made pope and young...

My point stands, if there are so many bucks over measly 140 in Alabama, why is the state only registering a very, very, very few pope and youngs which the requirement is only net 125?

I agree 100%. I have guided long enough to know most guys see a 120 inch buck they go to shaking and wanting to shoot it. A true 140 inch deer is a man.

It is so funny that alot of these people that are saying they would not pay to shoot 140" deer will pay to go to Kanasas or Illinois and 99% of them will shoot the first 140" deer that walks by, heck most would shoot the first 130" deer that walked by. Seems a bit hypocritical to me. I have been blessed to only shoot 2 deer over 140" in my life and both were with a bow in Illinois. I have only seen live 1 or 2 140" deer in Alabama and I have hunted some well managed places. A question for you macdaddy, why did you ask this question in the first place?

Just cause you kill it don't mean you have to put in the book or even talk about it.

here ya go neutral88, ya think thisuns close to 125???

I never have and never will pay to go on an outfitted or guided hunt just because I like to do things on my own, even though my success isn't nearly as high as it would be on paid hunts I'm sure. I do pay the money that it costs to be legal to hunt on Midwest public lands and see 140's there with decent regularity though.

Interesting comments, post some pictures of those deer that seem to dwarf the one posted. I would like to see what you have that doesn't meet P & Y minimum 125.

Here is one that grosses 121 7/8", nets 117 7/8".



And no I would not pay to go on a guided hunt for the purpose of shooting a whitetail. I am however, open to a DIY hunt for free range whitetails anywhere.

Sometimes I think everyone gets so caught up in the horns that they forget about what the point is for a lot of us - we hunt and maintain hunting properties b/c we love it!

No matter which way you shake a stick at it - paid hunt or join club or lease/own - you are still paying $$$$ for your deer no matter what size they are!

"I've got a 6" member."

"Well, I've got a 7" member."

"Well, I'VE got 3 members and all are over 8". Just because you have no idea how to gather 3 over 8" members unto yourself, doesn't mean nobody else does."

And so on and so forth......that's what these kinds of posts turn into every single time on here. A bunch of folks just DYING to brag and to throw the credentials of their kills out there for the world to see.

Those that say they wouldn't pay for an outfitter are just jealous!

The problem in Alabama is every partial of land basically is being hunted by somebody and the key to it is to be able to have alot of land that you can manage and maintain for years . I had to really educate myself quick on knowing what I was looking at and thru educating myself looking at deer's body and guessing there age I feel I have improved myself when i see a deer , I keep a digital camera with me at all times in the woods and I will take pics almost every hunt of what I see if I can I go back and study those pics to see if I made the right choice and 9 times out of 10 I made the right choice to let him walk , had guys say why didn't you kill him well hunting is about decisions and I try to make the right ones so maybe a fellow hunter will get a better deer the next year and i can truthfully say alot of hunters in our Club have benefited and got a good deer the next year , now fellow hunters have seen what I have been doing and now alot of them carry their cameras as well , we have been very fortunate and killed several deer over 140,150, and occasionally deer alot bigger , but Alabama has great potential if we educate ourselfs about deer age but we have to also realize every deer is not going to score 140 . I love to hunt but wouldn't feel right harvesting a deer either if somebody said there's a 150 that comes in at 1pm everday at that oak tree and I killed it , to me there's no satisfaction in that kill I didn't earn it and sure don't want to pay to kill it but everybody is different I'm
just glad God provides these animals and blesses us with this great sport of Hunting.

If you want to see the paper work on my 140" deer feel free to come by anytime, until that time probally be a real good idea if you do not call people liars.

Juggy also said "Hey guys...just got back from Illinois. Killed him on Halloween morning at about 10:00 at 12 yards. My first P&Y buck...my first 10 point too after all these years of hunting!"



If you can't post and brag here, where should you? I don't think www.ischattcrimson-n-white.com or www.iwhizorange-n-blue.com are the best places.

Congratulations on the 10 point by the way!

Come on man. I posted ONE TIME, to my teammates ONLY, to let them know how my trip went. That buck wasn't posted on a general or serious forum and won't ever be mentioned here again...not by me anyway. I brag on my son alot because I'm proud of him, but I don't do a whole bunch of bragging about my kills. Heck, I ain't got much to brag about....maybe that's why.

It's that whole "I'm a better hunter than you because I've got 5011 140's on the wall" attitude that I can't stand. I would rather be around a room full of loud mouth Democrat women than to listen to an arrogant deer hunter. Just one of my pet peeves I guess.

The trophy is in the eye of the beholder, if you want to pay someone to take you to kill a 140" deer go ahead. But its not for me. I have deer on the wall that a lot of people would have just hung the horns in the shed, but since I was hunting with my dad and grand dad they are trophies to me. If you are hunting just to say you killed a huge deer, it would probably be cheeper to just go on an outfitted hunt, instead of paying for a lease.

Apparently anything I post is taken as arrogance Jughead. I'm sorry you feel that way. I don't mean it that way. I just don't appreciate being called a liar, and I don't understand why my post was taken that way by you. I was responding to mackdaddy's post, which the last time I checked, wasn't a show of arrogance. Carry on....without me. You, and others like you, are precisely why I stopped saying anything on here about the deer I killed. Now I will once again crawl into the cave and keep them to myself.