I understand your perspective, and respect your training and background. I also realize that a website like that may not be the BEST resource to compare dog foods, but I do find it useful in that it does seem to compare many brands on an apples-to-apples basis. A website like that makes it easier for me to sort through the misinformation and marketing that companies put on the front of a bag to keep you from looking at the back of it.

I feed my dog Victor, because I am comfortable with the ingredients and the company.