I like the 200 acre per member suggestion.
No 4 wheelers/loud vehicles.
Pulse hunting - close for the typically deadest times (for bucks), but not arbitrarily close days of weeks because no one can be on same schedule.
Kill does with bows and not on food plots.
Didn't read whole thread, but if you don't have a club limit of 2 bucks maybe do that too.
Just some rambling thoughts.......~