For a deer hunting rifle in the SE United States, for shots on deer at reasonable, ethical ranges, my answer is: it doesn't matter. Either brand you listed (or most any other brand for that matter) will do the job quite nicely right out of the box.
Buy the rifle that fits you best, has the best look and feel to you, and the one whose trigger feels best to you.
Now if your hobby is shooting, I have a different answer for you.
