Same buck across 3 years. Age is the key.

Year 1:

Year 2:

Year 3:

What ages y’all thinking?

4

My 2 cents is 2,3 and 4....

All those pics are in August if the time is correct. So I'm going to say 3,4, and 5.

I might be too old by a year but those summer pictures always make them look younger than they are

2,3,4 maybe.

He’s not 3,4,5

I could see a scenario of him being 1,2,3

I’ve had quite a few stellar 1 year olds with that much antler over the years. They are truly special animals.

We figured him at 2 the first year, which would make him 4 this year. Had quite a few daylight pics last season after we killed one of the mature bucks. Previously he would disappear after summer. Found both sheds last year and scored right at 120” I believe assuming a 16” spread. Never really considered the possibility he was 1 the first year, but if that were true he really would be special at 5. We plan on giving him a pass this season and hoping the neighbors don’t see him.

He was likely 2 that first year. I’m just throwing out the possibility he was one given his body characteristics compared to that other one year old he was with. All of these are one year olds and off to a superb start.

I don’t think the last 2 pics are the same deer. His brow tines go straight up. The 2 previous years his brows pointed inward towards each other.

We had deer in texas we tracked from birth to death…on a rare occasion thatd be over a decade…one in particular lived 14 years…at 1.5 he was like a 115in 12pt…rack wudnt outside his ears…cute little feller…he broke 200 as a 4yo an broke 230 as a 6yo…at 7yo…he was approximately 245in completely native all natural south texas deer..in a low fence to boot…at 8yo he wouldnd break 130and he stayed a turd until his 14th season…for whatever reason..and we never really figured it out..he blew back up to like 249…bigger than hed ever been ever…an they shot him that year…teeth were in bad shape but not completely gone. He turned out to be one of the biggest deer we ever killed off that 45k acres…he did have a nice rainy year as well

His G4s are a dead giveaway. They are almost 90 degrees off of the main beam. He definitely put on some brow tine this year.

Unless they’re tagged, it’s mostly a guess if it’s the same deer or not.

He’s had a swollen spot on his front left leg the last two years too.

I killed a deer in texas..i had 3 years worth of pictures ( i thought😳)…140in 8pt…just a dang stud of a deer..bigger bodied than all the other deer, and he just bullied every other buck around no matter how big…he was a beast. Well, i killed him..an his teeth barely aged 5.5…i thought…they aint no way..he has looked exactly the same for three years..an he looked studly and old…low and behold..i was goin through some old files on the computer a few weeks later and i found some camera surveys from years back….that deer had had 2 different names by 2 different interns goin back 6 years…we had 9yo worth of pics of him when i killed him…we guessed he was 6.5 when i shot him..but he was probly more like 12.5. After doin some math…an lookin at pictures…when he was 4.5- 7.5..ish…he looked like a different deer..an i mean…he was a 190in dang monster…he had splits an kickers goin everywhere…even when he changed the firs time when the second intern found him…he was a typical big basket rack 12pt..probably 170…by the time the 3rd and 4th(me) came along…he done turned into a turdy old 140in 8pt🤠