Honestly, I don't think you can over do it, but I'm sure there comes a point of diminishing return too.

You are probably right. And I am all for a better way of doing things. Been talking to CNC about some things we can do to improve the soil. But until we get to that point, I’ll just keep putting out what the soil samples call for, which has been a lot unfortunately. But I’m not gonna skimp on the fields. Too much time and money goes into my place to half ass the fields

This PLUS make sure who ever in your club is in charge of planting READS them and fertilizes accordingly. Don't ask me why I say this. Wish I didn't know

Turns out, another member soil tested some of the plots last year, and, in fact, many of the one's he did say the Ph is ok, and recommended no lime.

When I planted m plots in Pike county they recommended using 250# per acre of 15 - 0 - 15 instead of the old triple 13 and my plots seem to be a lot prettier this year, but we have had ample rain.

Phosphorus (P) middle number builds up in soil and doesn’t move or leach out of fields like nitrogen and Potassium do. P build up is common in fields that have ever had manure applied. So the recommendation with no P is common. Another reason to soil test