Aldeer.com

1911 Compact

Posted By: AC870

1911 Compact - 02/23/20 02:03 AM


Who carries one and your thoughts?
Our turkey patterning turned into pistol shooting this afternoon. Only gun I shot well was my brother’s 1911.
It got me thinking.
Posted By: Out back

Re: 1911 Compact - 02/23/20 02:16 AM

Ask Shaw. He ended with my compact 1911 after some horse trading.
Posted By: AU7MM08

Re: 1911 Compact - 02/23/20 02:24 AM

I've heard reliability often drops off once you get smaller than a commander length.
Posted By: Rooster600

Re: 1911 Compact - 02/23/20 02:40 AM

I carry a kimber ultra 2. I love it. Haven’t had any issues with reliability. I shoot 185’s mostly, helps with the recoil.
Posted By: dave260rem!

Re: 1911 Compact - 02/23/20 02:54 AM

The lightweight commander 4.25 inch is small as you would want.
Posted By: Cactus_buck

Re: 1911 Compact - 02/23/20 04:04 AM

Originally Posted by Out back
Ask Shaw. He ended with my compact 1911 after some horse trading.



Is it still considered a compact when a Keebler elf holds the gun?
Posted By: Shaw

Re: 1911 Compact - 02/23/20 04:32 AM

I’ve never carried it, but I shoot it better than any other pistol I own. Mine isn’t technically a compact though. I believe it would be considered more of a commander. It has a 4” barrel, but it’s the standard height.
Posted By: Wiley Coyote

Re: 1911 Compact - 02/23/20 05:36 AM

My Kimber Super Carry Pro is the most accurate centerfire handgun I've ever shot and carries very well. As for concealment, the rounded butt is a must. Aluminum frame and steel slide make it a great carry piece from a weight standpoint but a high quality holster is a must to get it all the way there.
Posted By: Scout308

Re: 1911 Compact - 02/23/20 05:37 AM

I have a Colt Defender 45acp that has functioned flawlessly using Wilson Combat magazines. The factory Colt Mags suck!
Posted By: UncleHuck

Re: 1911 Compact - 02/23/20 12:54 PM


Lots of compact 1911 pistols have a reputation for function issues. If you buy a Sig or a Kimber, those are not a factor.
Posted By: R_H_Clark

Re: 1911 Compact - 02/23/20 01:20 PM

A Glock 36 is the best compact 1911 sized pistol I have found. I've owned several new 1911's and just got tired of having to "tweek" them to get them to go bang every time.
Posted By: globe

Re: 1911 Compact - 02/23/20 03:07 PM

I had a Springfield EMP that was a great shooter. Only thing it didn’t shoot was some reloads. Really hate I sold that one.
Posted By: UncleHuck

Re: 1911 Compact - 02/23/20 05:07 PM


glocks are ugly, have no soul, and the company owner is a major POS who cheated his own family out of millions. I will never buy a new one, and I won't own a used one for longer than it takes me to trade it.

Good 1911 pistols require no "tweaking" to run correctly. They may, however, need a few hundred rounds to wear in the parts, which I do anyway with any CCW that I buy.

glocks generally don't need this, as they are deliberately made to slack tolerances, similar to AK rifles, which also suck and are ugly.
Posted By: R_H_Clark

Re: 1911 Compact - 02/23/20 06:17 PM

Originally Posted by UncleHuck

glocks are ugly, have no soul, and the company owner is a major POS who cheated his own family out of millions. I will never buy a new one, and I won't own a used one for longer than it takes me to trade it.

Good 1911 pistols require no "tweaking" to run correctly. They may, however, need a few hundred rounds to wear in the parts, which I do anyway with any CCW that I buy.

glocks generally don't need this, as they are deliberately made to slack tolerances, similar to AK rifles, which also suck and are ugly.


All that may be true but any stock Glock will have a much less percentage of failures compared to any stock 1911. I would also be willing to bet that a known Glock would fire a lot more rounds without any mishap,than any known,custom or whatever 1911. My little 36 has never in nearly 20 years failed to go bang when I pulled the trigger.
Posted By: csregor

Re: 1911 Compact - 02/23/20 11:35 PM

I just got a kimber pro carry custom shop1911 .45 in a big trade and thinking about moving it if you’re interested let me know. I can send you some pics
Posted By: Wiley Coyote

Re: 1911 Compact - 02/24/20 12:44 AM

Originally Posted by csregor
I just got a kimber pro carry 1911 .45 in a big trade and thinking about moving it if you’re interested let me know. I can send you same pics


If the price is right this is THE 1911 for a carry piece.
Posted By: Sandmtnslayer

Re: 1911 Compact - 02/24/20 01:03 AM

Originally Posted by Rooster600
I carry a kimber ultra 2. I love it. Haven’t had any issues with reliability. I shoot 185’s mostly, helps with the recoil.

Have one also
Posted By: roadkill

Re: 1911 Compact - 02/24/20 10:47 AM

I don't carry it but have had a Colt Officers's Model for about 10 years. Heavy, limited rounds, challenging to shoot in that it takes me a couple of magazines to adjust to it after shooting the full sized guns. reliability has always been good, accuracy is great after I get it dialed in. Weight is a factor.We all open carry at Larry's and joke about you can tell who has a 1911 on that day because they have to stop every few steps and pull their pants up.
Posted By: Goatkiller

Re: 1911 Compact - 02/24/20 03:16 PM

I don't know how many I have been around and shot going to be in the hundreds and hundreds but once you go smaller than a commander your reliability goes down I don't care who's name is engraved on the side of it .... even if it says Les Baer. I seems like they all feed ball ammo but I've seen a lot of jamming going on with one particular round vs another.... the more compact you get the more those issues crop up.

Posted By: DonH

Re: 1911 Compact - 02/25/20 07:03 PM

I too carry a Kimber ultra carry 2 and have zero bad things to say , it eats every thing I have run thru it. ,
© 2024 ALDEER.COM