Aldeer.com

Lowndes County Smasher!!!!

Posted By: Skullworks

Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 06:27 PM

From Facebook...

[Linked Image]

[Linked Image]

[Linked Image]
Posted By: Coosa1

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 06:29 PM

Daggum
Posted By: Turkey_neck

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 06:30 PM

Sumbitch that's a toad.
Posted By: canvasback

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 06:30 PM

shocked
Posted By: BamaGrad85

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 06:36 PM

thumbup thumbup
Posted By: bdw32

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 06:36 PM

My goodness
Posted By: Backporch

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 06:40 PM

Very nice.
Posted By: Whitetaillane

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 06:45 PM

Congrats to the hunter that is a outstanding buck
Posted By: bward85

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 06:51 PM

Damn fine buck!!
Posted By: bigcountry692001

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 06:56 PM

Wow!
Posted By: 280Rem.

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 06:57 PM

Awesome Buck!!
Posted By: BREEZE1

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 06:57 PM

Heck of a nice'un.
Posted By: lefthorn

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 06:57 PM

Yhatzee!!
Posted By: Coosa1

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 06:58 PM

Saw a post about it on FB saying they're measuring him at like 186"
Posted By: Ar1220

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 07:02 PM

That is a stud of a buck....congrats to the hunter
Posted By: Bamabucks14

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 07:03 PM

Whoa! That’s a stud
Posted By: foldemup

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 07:05 PM

Finally someone that actually looks happy that they killed a stud! Congrats to him!
Posted By: WmHunter

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 07:06 PM

Outstanding deer!!

Congrats!!
Posted By: CeeHawk37

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 07:14 PM

Nice! Congrats to the hunter!
Posted By: Hoytdad10

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 07:15 PM

Awesome buck
Posted By: lances

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 07:17 PM

Holy cow that’s a niccun
Posted By: dirkdaddy

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 07:17 PM

Holy. Crap! What a buck deer!!
Posted By: Goatkiller

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 07:19 PM


Holy shucks! We don't have the right kinda soil to grow bucks that big!
Posted By: ikillbux

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 07:24 PM

Originally Posted by foldemup
Finally someone that actually looks happy that they killed a stud! Congrats to him!


I would be crying like a fool! grin

I like that dude's gun!!
Posted By: mauvilla

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 07:33 PM

Ridiculous !dang that’s nice
Posted By: mzzy

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 07:38 PM



Dang, look at those bases
Posted By: Shaw

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 07:43 PM

That’s a full grown one.
Posted By: Autseed

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 07:49 PM

Congratulations! Beautiful buck!
Posted By: booth2

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 08:01 PM

Originally Posted by foldemup
Finally someone that actually looks happy that they killed a stud! Congrats to him!


You said it man and I totally agree!
Posted By: Morris

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 08:05 PM

Geesh what a damn deer!
Posted By: Claims Rep.

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 08:06 PM

Wow! Congrats to that hunter. Heck of a buck!
Posted By: sj22

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 08:07 PM




My goodness what a deer!
Posted By: BCLC

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 08:14 PM

Wow.
Posted By: Shaneomac2

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 08:26 PM

Originally Posted by Turkey_neck
Sumbitch that's a toad.
Posted By: foghorn

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 08:30 PM

Beautiful!! Congrats
Posted By: gatorbait154

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 08:53 PM

STUD!!!
Posted By: MarksOutdoors

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 08:59 PM



Lowndes, Ohio?????
Posted By: jmudler

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 09:13 PM

good googly moogally
Posted By: jb20

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 09:24 PM

Originally Posted by mzzy


Dang, look at those bases

Ya that's a thick rack congrats for whoevever killed it
Posted By: sj22

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 09:25 PM





Buddy that lives down that way just told me it was a pen deer, Fort Deposit Outfitters, I don’t care either way it’s huge!!
Posted By: 257wbymag

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 09:26 PM

Originally Posted by sj22




Buddy that lives down that way just told me it was a pen deer, Fort Deposit Outfitters, I don’t care either way it’s huge!!


Well that didn’t take long.
Posted By: bama1971

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 09:49 PM

Originally Posted by sj22




Buddy that lives down that way just told me it was a pen deer, Fort Deposit Outfitters, I don’t care either way it’s huge!!


It was a hell of a place before the fence. Not sure why they fenced it

Guy owns a trucking company south of there, LSU fans.

Beautiful place
Posted By: Skullworks

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 10:07 PM

Post said free range but I don’t know personally.
Posted By: Sdyar

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 10:58 PM

Damitboy !
Posted By: JohnG

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 11:06 PM

Why two locks on the Yeti cooler?
Posted By: top cat

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/25/19 11:33 PM

Awesome buck
Posted By: Swampdrummin

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/26/19 12:00 AM



Originally Posted by Skullworks
Post said free range but I don’t know personally.


Free range in the big pen.
Posted By: Racksrus

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/26/19 01:01 AM

Well if he is a pen deer that changes everything. There are lot of posts these days claiming free range but they are pen deer. But what's sad is some of these folks think that free range or pen , it doesn't matter. But it matters tremendously !
Posted By: TwoRs

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/26/19 01:44 AM

Congrats to the hunter, lifetime buck!
Posted By: mike35549

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/26/19 01:47 AM

That's a goodun.
Posted By: canvasback

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/26/19 02:57 AM

There is a youtube video on Fort Deposit Outfitters that explains their setup..watched about the first thirty seconds.....two separate parcels of 400 and 600 acres. Deer are separated with one group being Canadian genetics and the other northern genetics. Ho Hum....next
Posted By: Traweek

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/26/19 03:04 AM

Yeah
Originally Posted by JohnG
Why two locks on the Yeti cooler?


Cause those are his Natty Lights and you can’t have any.
Posted By: 257wbymag

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/26/19 03:07 AM

His and his locks probly.
Posted By: jawbone

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/26/19 03:14 AM

Originally Posted by JohnG
Why two locks on the Yeti cooler?


Because Lowndes County thieves laugh at only one lock.
Posted By: Jmxinc

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/26/19 03:19 AM

That’s a big one !
Posted By: Standbanger

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/26/19 03:40 AM

Anybody got the number to outfitter
Posted By: HootOwl

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/26/19 04:30 AM

Goodun!!
Posted By: Reloader79

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/26/19 01:48 PM

Freakin bruiser!
Posted By: leroycnbucks

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/26/19 01:58 PM

WOW! What a hoss! Congratulations to the hunter!


Just read all the posts about it’s a pen deer. Still congratulations to the hunter.
Posted By: Cuz-Pat

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/26/19 02:44 PM

A brute.
Posted By: Sasquatch Lives

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/26/19 02:56 PM

Aw man I was hoping it was a wild deer. Gotta keep them Yetis locked up haha. My old cooler keeps the brew cold and nobody wants to steal it haha.
Posted By: rulebreaker

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/26/19 04:18 PM

No comment.
Posted By: timbercruiser

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/26/19 04:26 PM

Does the 400 acre pen qualify as a little pen and the 600 acre pen qualify as a big pen?
Posted By: Racksrus

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/26/19 05:58 PM

I'm in sales and I sure would like to run up on some of these guys who can't tell the difference in real vs.not so real ! Don't get me wrong. If you want to shoot a deer in a pen ,have at it. With the way some of our hunting is I can see why a guy might go to a pen. As a matter of fact I have a buddy who has invited me to his penned area and shoot one. But if I did don't go to congratulating me like I was some kind of Geronimo and pulled off a great deed !
Posted By: CarbonClimber1

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/26/19 06:03 PM

Difference between fencing property and bein a deer breeder, purty deer none the less
Posted By: Skullworks

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/26/19 06:50 PM

Anyone verified it’s a pen deer yet?
Posted By: Reloader79

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/27/19 12:13 AM

Well if it is a pen deer that changes the perspective.
Posted By: UncleJethro

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/27/19 04:46 PM

Well if it is a pen raised deer not sure why the county would even be relevant in the post headline. I had conversation over breakfast this morning about this deer and now I come back to see it may be a pen raised high fence whatever you want to call it, deer.
Posted By: fourfive45

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/29/19 04:26 PM

Looks like the deer has had a tag in its ear at some point
Posted By: Huntinman

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/29/19 05:07 PM

We'll all be hunting pen deer before too long.
Posted By: Remington270

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/29/19 05:09 PM

Originally Posted by timbercruiser
Does the 400 acre pen qualify as a little pen and the 600 acre pen qualify as a big pen?


According to some folks I've heard: "Deer in pens are just as hard to hunt as wild deer".

I wonder if they're as "hard to kill" as pen-raised quail? laugh
Posted By: blumsden

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/29/19 05:12 PM

May have low fenced it to keep all the damn free ranging dogs out. As long as breeder raised deer weren't introduced, who cares? Deer can jump fences and come and go as they please. My cousin had an 80 acre coyote pen to run his dogs in. Deer would jump the fence all the time. They were still wild deer.
Posted By: BCLC

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/29/19 06:32 PM

Originally Posted by blumsden
May have low fenced it to keep all the damn free ranging dogs out. As long as breeder raised deer weren't introduced, who cares? Deer can jump fences and come and go as they please. My cousin had an 80 acre coyote pen to run his dogs in. Deer would jump the fence all the time. They were still wild deer.


Originally Posted by canvasback
There is a youtube video on Fort Deposit Outfitters that explains their setup..watched about the first thirty seconds.....two separate parcels of 400 and 600 acres. Deer are separated with one group being Canadian genetics and the other northern genetics. Ho Hum....next
Posted By: Skullworks

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/29/19 09:24 PM

Deer was killed near Hayneville.
Posted By: leroyb

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/29/19 09:36 PM

Originally Posted by Skullworks
Deer was killed near Hayneville.


Near Hayneville in a high fence or wild?
Posted By: Skullworks

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/29/19 09:40 PM

Originally Posted by leroyb
Originally Posted by Skullworks
Deer was killed near Hayneville.


Near Hayneville in a high fence or wild?


Free range is what I'm told.
Posted By: 280REM

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/29/19 11:07 PM

Originally Posted by Skullworks
Originally Posted by leroyb
Originally Posted by Skullworks
Deer was killed near Hayneville.


Near Hayneville in a high fence or wild?


Free range is what I'm told.


I hunt near Hayneville. I guess it's possible. That would be an exceptional Lowndes Co. deer, but not out of the question, There's a high fence operation near there too.
Posted By: leroycnbucks

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/29/19 11:22 PM

Hayneville is in the flatous region of Lowndes county.
Posted By: rich

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/29/19 11:33 PM

thats a great buck. what i have been wanting all my life.
Posted By: Skullworks

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/30/19 01:54 AM

Originally Posted by 280REM
Originally Posted by Skullworks
Originally Posted by leroyb
Originally Posted by Skullworks
Deer was killed near Hayneville.


Near Hayneville in a high fence or wild?


Free range is what I'm told.


I hunt near Hayneville. I guess it's possible. That would be an exceptional Lowndes Co. deer, but not out of the question, There's a high fence operation near there too.


I used to hunt in Mt Willing.
Posted By: James

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/30/19 01:58 AM




Looks like a free range Buck Deer
Posted By: Halfrack

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 01/30/19 02:06 AM

Big deer in Lowndes county,not surprised if it was free range.
Posted By: Skullworks

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/13/19 07:39 PM

[Linked Image]
Posted By: Runningdeer

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/13/19 07:41 PM

Guess that settles the issue. Great deer.
Posted By: centralala

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/13/19 07:43 PM

What's the #1 in Lowndes and who killed it?
Posted By: dirkdaddy

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/13/19 08:39 PM

Hell yea great to here it was actually free range. Easily the best deer kill I've seen this year. Congrats to Robert.
Posted By: jallencrockett

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/13/19 09:03 PM

Jimmy Judge killed a nontypical on Judge road that was #3 statewide. I assume thats the buck that beats it.
Posted By: BPI

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/13/19 11:09 PM

He's long arming it !!!!
Posted By: Dkhargroves

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/13/19 11:50 PM

Originally Posted by jallencrockett
Jimmy Judge killed a nontypical on Judge road that was #3 statewide. I assume thats the buck that beats it.

Done some work on judge rd, big deer in that area
Posted By: slippinlipjr

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/14/19 03:54 AM

Speaking of insane lease prices......
Posted By: leroycnbucks

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/14/19 12:34 PM

Congratulations to Robert! What a great deer!
Posted By: olemossy

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/14/19 12:47 PM

Awesome deer congrats to the hunter.
Posted By: jallencrockett

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/14/19 12:58 PM

There are several high fences around hayneville. One local had a small pen and raised / let out boocoo northern deer in the area as it has been told too me by a lifetime local. Most of the big deer I am aware of that have been killed within close proximity of the former small pen. The highfence on scretty road had a fence get washed out via flood a couple years ago. It may have been free range but the torn ear sure is SUSPECT.
Posted By: Shaw

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/14/19 01:05 PM

I guess they never tear an ear fighting. Looks like this one my nephew killed in Picken County last year is suspect. crazy

[Linked Image]
Posted By: WmHunter

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/14/19 08:32 PM

Originally Posted by Runningdeer
Guess that settles the issue. Great deer.


It does,

And it is a shame that some people always raise a question about someone else's big buck once the pictures
of the deer are posted on the internet.
Posted By: Forrestgump1

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/14/19 09:36 PM

Apparently he withdrew it from the whitetail records? Not trying to stir the pot just saw that he withdrew it for some reason.
Posted By: Skullworks

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/14/19 11:36 PM

Originally Posted by Forrestgump1
Apparently he withdrew it from the whitetail records? Not trying to stir the pot just saw that he withdrew it for some reason.



Hmmm....
Posted By: Skullworks

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 12:17 AM

I can only think of one reason for it to be withdrawn.
Posted By: leroycnbucks

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 12:59 PM

Damn. More drama. Does anybody know the hunter? I wish he would come on here and tell us about the hunt. I remember bucks that big in the area in the seventies when there was an abundance of soybean fields.
Posted By: Sdyar

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 01:27 PM

Do pens have buck sanctuaries, daisy chsin locks on the yeti.....damn.
Posted By: lefthorn

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 04:35 PM

Well apparently there is some post on Facebook by Alabama whitetail records that this deer was NOT free range
Posted By: BamaWes14

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 04:49 PM

Yea I seen the Alabama whitetail records and it’s saying it was from the fort deposit outfitters high fence. I don’t understand why people can’t just be honest. You know a deer like that is going to get the attention of a lot of people and the truth will come out
Posted By: lefthorn

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 04:53 PM

I guess some people just want you to think they are great hunters
Posted By: Skullworks

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 04:54 PM

Well that sucks!
Posted By: Dkhargroves

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 04:58 PM

Only thing I can think of as to why it was withdrawn was high fence or an illegal kill (or allegations of)
Posted By: Dkhargroves

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 04:59 PM

But, there are some big ass deer in lowndes county so I won’t discredit it could be free range. Slit in the ear is strange but could be from a fight (as ironic as that would be)
Posted By: BhamFred

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 04:59 PM

well chitt.
Posted By: Coosa1

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 05:09 PM

[Linked Image]
Posted By: booth2

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 05:10 PM

What an idiot.
Posted By: Runningdeer

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 05:13 PM

I retract my earlier remarks. Good grief.
Posted By: BamaWes14

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 05:19 PM

I seen in the comments where he isn’t allowed to ever enter a deer now
Posted By: jb20

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 05:43 PM

Originally Posted by booth2
What an idiot.
Posted By: jlbuc10

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 05:46 PM

I thought it was strange that AWR said they could verify that it was free range by just holding the antlers and scoring it.
Posted By: alhawk

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 06:11 PM

A douche and his money have now had their 15 minutes of Fame.
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 06:29 PM

Polygraph, would eliminate all drama related to these things. Never seen much questioning of bass tourney results. Been questioning of every big deer ever killed.
Posted By: jb20

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 06:30 PM

Originally Posted by sgtred
Polygraph, would eliminate all drama related to these things. Never seen much questioning of bass tourney results. Been questioning of every big deer ever killed.

They have been sum bass tourney cheaters get busted round here
Posted By: NWALJM

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 06:35 PM

That deer ain't nothin compared to the free range genetics in the mountainous area of Pelham.
Posted By: tbest3

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 06:36 PM



Stupid.
Posted By: AUdeerhunter

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 06:44 PM

Good grief!! What a goober...

The mountains of Pelham say “Hi”
Posted By: dirkdaddy

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 06:46 PM

Jesus Christ what a friggin Mickey Mouse show. That dude deserves some flogging for letting g that deer get all the way into the record books, just to be taken away
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 06:46 PM

That's the whole point,of polygraph, dudes got busted before declared winners.
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 06:49 PM

Polygraph would eliminate all the bull doo too. No, he shot at night, no he shot it over corn, no, he shot off the road, no he shot it on another fellers place and on and on
Posted By: MarksOutdoors

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 06:54 PM


I've gotten to the point that I'm just completely skeptical whenever
I see one of these posts because of stuff like this.
Posted By: fromthedepths

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 06:57 PM

Ole gloryhound !stuff like this makes me keep my deer pics to myself even though they’re legal .
Posted By: outdoors1

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 07:05 PM

If the big deer walks out 2 foot outside the big pen with shooter waiting will he qualify for Alabama scoring system or does he have to walk around for a couple of days?
Posted By: booth2

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 07:12 PM

Yes sir...unless I know the person, I am always skeptical to big deer pics and how they were really killed.

Originally Posted by MarksOutdoors

I've gotten to the point that I'm just completely skeptical whenever
I see one of these posts because of stuff like this.
Posted By: lefthorn

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 07:20 PM

Originally Posted by outdoors1
If the big deer walks out 2 foot outside the big pen with shooter waiting will he qualify for Alabama scoring system or does he have to walk around for a couple of days?


I don’t think that would qualify as “fair chase”
Posted By: jb20

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 07:21 PM

Makes u wonder if any more made it to the books
Posted By: abolt300

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 07:26 PM

Here's an honest question. Why would someone claim that a deer that was killed in an enclosure on a pay hunt as being a free-range deer?? Most of those bucks are cataloged with pics on them on the high fence's website for advertising. I mean it is just stupid. Word will get out. Is a day of internet fame worth losing your reputation for life? I just do not understand this mentality and it seems to be a common occurrence that replays itself on here year after year.
Posted By: centralala

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 07:37 PM

Originally Posted by abolt300
Here's an honest question. Why would someone claim that a deer that was killed in an enclosure on a pay hunt as being a free-range deer?? Most of those bucks are cataloged with pics on them on the high fence's website for advertising. I mean it is just stupid. Word will get out. Is a day of internet fame worth losing your reputation for life? I just do not understand this mentality and it seems to be a common occurrence that replays itself on here year after year.



It's been going on well before the internet. At least that is what Owen Walton and Mitch Rompallo told me. grin

As far as a polygraph, I once failed one and I was telling the truth. It was part of a hiring process for a job but I was still hired. One question they said that was coming back as being untruthful on I was telling the truth. Doesn't matter now but I don't trust them after that.
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 08:25 PM

Polygraph are not full proof, but I would say, best option they have to cut down on all the drama associated with big bucks
Posted By: leroycnbucks

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 08:44 PM

Originally Posted by MarksOutdoors

I've gotten to the point that I'm just completely skeptical whenever
I see one of these posts because of stuff like this.



Me too. I’m genuinely happy for any hunter that kills a big buck and want to congratulate them on their success. Plus it gets me motivated to be a better hunter. But here lately just seems like a lot of drama and it’s brought on by the hunter himself by not being honest and forthright with the hunting community.
Posted By: jallencrockett

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 08:44 PM

I'd say you can start wondering about the "hunter" when he has a staged professional photo and is not even looking into the camera but rather is staring into the distance with the glory of his mind...

In the area that it was reported I have friends and friends of friends that own a large amount of that area and the deer was not from their land or neighbors so yeah I was skeptical and my buddies just flat out when they saw the pic within 5 seconds said it was high fence.
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 08:57 PM

Do any of y'all think that trophy hunting has become so much, the be all,and end all thing in deer hunting. That and people's competitive drive has contributed to the drama we see unfold. Should there even be a record book
Posted By: Dkhargroves

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 09:07 PM

What a dumbass. He knew that buck wasn’t free range n still entered it. He otta have his ass whooped for that
Posted By: hunterbuck

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 09:12 PM

Originally Posted by centralala



It's been going on well before the internet. At least that is what Owen Walton and Mitch Rompallo told me. grin



Owen Walton...now there's a name I haven't heard in many years. Remember reading about his "new record buck" in Alabama Game and Fish as a teen, and being amazed. Didn't hear until years later that it was a fake. No internet back then, of course.

I wonder if anyone from this site actually knows him?
Posted By: jallencrockett

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 09:21 PM

Originally Posted by hunterbuck
Originally Posted by centralala



It's been going on well before the internet. At least that is what Owen Walton and Mitch Rompallo told me. grin



Owen Walton...now there's a name I haven't heard in many years. Remember reading about his "new record buck" in Alabama Game and Fish as a teen, and being amazed. Didn't hear until years later that it was a fake. No internet back then, of course.

I wonder if anyone from this site actually knows him?



Wasnt that the guy who shot / poached his deer in Georgia and told every product name for last second shot for Alabama record?

Of course the dumbest has to be a tie for the dude that poached the bham zoo deer and then took it in to qualify for the Alabama Record Book and the idiot that broke thru Newell'S Fence on Bell Road in Montgomery and killed the huge pet deer; that was his 3rd strike as a felon and he got LIFE IN JAIL.
Posted By: centralala

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 09:24 PM

Originally Posted by jallencrockett
Originally Posted by hunterbuck
Originally Posted by centralala



It's been going on well before the internet. At least that is what Owen Walton and Mitch Rompallo told me. grin



Owen Walton...now there's a name I haven't heard in many years. Remember reading about his "new record buck" in Alabama Game and Fish as a teen, and being amazed. Didn't hear until years later that it was a fake. No internet back then, of course.

I wonder if anyone from this site actually knows him?



Wasnt that the guy who shot / poached his deer in Georgia and told every product name for last second shot for Alabama record?

Of course the dumbest has to be a tie for the dude that poached the bham zoo deer and then took it in to qualify for the Alabama Record Book and the idiot that broke thru Newell'S Fence on Bell Road in Montgomery and killed the huge pet deer; that was his 3rd strike as a felon and he got LIFE IN JAIL.


Walton was shed antlers he stole in Ga....or so said because the rack came up missing. He claimed to have killed it in Macon Co. Al. the best I recall.
Posted By: lances

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 09:26 PM

Crazy what some people will do for the spotlight
Posted By: hunterbuck

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 09:27 PM

Originally Posted by centralala



It's been going on well before the internet. At least that is what Owen Walton and Mitch Rompallo told me. grin



Owen Walton...now there's a name I haven't heard in many years. Remember reading about his "new record buck" in Alabama Game and Fish as a teen, and being amazed. Didn't hear until years later that it was a fake. No internet back then, of course.

I wonder if anyone from this site actually knows him?
Originally Posted by jallencrockett
Originally Posted by hunterbuck
Originally Posted by centralala



It's been going on well before the internet. At least that is what Owen Walton and Mitch Rompallo told me. grin



Owen Walton...now there's a name I haven't heard in many years. Remember reading about his "new record buck" in Alabama Game and Fish as a teen, and being amazed. Didn't hear until years later that it was a fake. No internet back then, of course.

I wonder if anyone from this site actually knows him?



Wasnt that the guy who shot / poached his deer in Georgia and told every product name for last second shot for Alabama record?


Nah. He borrowed a set of sheds from a buddy in Georgia, then told the buddy that the sheds got stolen. Two or three years later, the sheds showed up on a mount that Owen claimed to have killed. Guy busted him because there were a couple of scoring marks from a disc on the rack, where he ran over it with a tractor when he found the sheds.
Posted By: centralala

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 09:31 PM

Originally Posted by sgtred
Polygraph are not full proof, but I would say, best option they have to cut down on all the drama associated with big bucks



I would hope knowing one would be required would be a deterrent. But you know how people are. I will never take another one because of my bad experience and knowing I was telling the truth. But it's their club and their rules and if you want in then play by the rules. I'm no threat of having to take a polygraph with them with a record book deer anyway.
Posted By: centralala

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 09:39 PM

Originally Posted by sgtred
Do any of y'all think that trophy hunting has become so much, the be all,and end all thing in deer hunting. That and people's competitive drive has contributed to the drama we see unfold. Should there even be a record book



You've been around it daily for many, many years. You know it's not the same. Better or worse?? Depends on personal perspective and age. Im 51 so I've seen alot over the last 40+ years. I will never be in another club and will only hunt by myself. Too much drama (and competition) for me or at least it has always been to me. If I take someone hunting i don't hunt. This has been the best for me.
Posted By: James

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 10:42 PM

Originally Posted by centralala
Originally Posted by sgtred
Polygraph are not full proof, but I would say, best option they have to cut down on all the drama associated with big bucks



I would hope knowing one would be required would be a deterrent. But you know how people are. I will never take another one because of my bad experience and knowing I was telling the truth. But it's their club and their rules and if you want in then play by the rules. I'm no threat of having to take a polygraph with them with a record book deer anyway.


I won't take a poly for simple fact that I'm a nervous fk as it is, so i would probably fail screw that
Posted By: eskimo270

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 10:59 PM

Originally Posted by outdoors1
If the big deer walks out 2 foot outside the big pen with shooter waiting will he qualify for Alabama scoring system or does he have to walk around for a couple of days?

Hurricane Michael blew down alot of high fences in southeast Alabama, north Florida and southwest Georgia, I wonder if this affects the record books?
Posted By: Anonymous

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/15/19 11:59 PM

Hmm, whitetail record guys little resistant,to polygraph, they say cost prohibitive. So, far, hunters seem somewhat resistant to that idea. Surprising really, makes you wonder
Posted By: Racksrus

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/16/19 01:23 AM

It's tough,but Stupid can be fixed.
Posted By: Sasquatch Lives

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/16/19 02:15 AM

Thanks to everyone who helped rat out this idiot. Sick of this crap. Anybody know this guy?
Posted By: Big Game Hunter

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/16/19 03:07 AM

Breeder buck from a high fence down that way is what I was told.

Alabama whitetail records have rejected it as an entry.
Posted By: Thefofive

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/16/19 05:09 AM

What some ppl won't do for attention and recognition. What an idiot!!! Scumbag!!! Dude, you're a POS trying to pull a nasty one over all us deer hunters.

No sympathy for you man!!!!!!!!!!!! Simply put, you're a POS!
Posted By: OlTimer

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/16/19 10:36 AM

Owen Walton was a fake. Nikon even sponsored him before he got exposed. A good friend of mine bought a Nikon scope after Walton's "kill" and boy did I have some fun with my friend! Now, here's a question. Do these high fence deer get reported to Game Check? Deer hunting fakes are nothing new, it just does not take as long to expose them.
Posted By: Bamabucks14

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/16/19 01:19 PM

Wow, that guy should be embarrassed and ashamed. He’s got a chit eatin’ Grin anyways.
Posted By: Skullworks

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/16/19 02:39 PM

I read that the deer had a name. SMDH. Wonder how much it cost?
Posted By: rulebreaker

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/16/19 02:57 PM

Originally Posted by rulebreaker
No comment.


My statement from 1/26/19. ^^^^

Anytime you see a HUGE buck and a $3K gun and the hunter wearing $1K worth clothing and gear, you can just about guarantee that it's a 'high fence' kill.
Posted By: Cuz-Pat

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/16/19 03:13 PM

Wonder how much that guy paid to pump up his ego?

Not impressed at all now that the truth has been revealed. rolleyes
Posted By: Coosa1

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/16/19 03:16 PM

Originally Posted by rulebreaker
Originally Posted by rulebreaker
No comment.


My statement from 1/26/19. ^^^^

Anytime you see a HUGE buck and a $3K gun and the hunter wearing $1K worth clothing and gear, you can just about guarantee that it's a 'high fence' kill.


I carry a $2k+ rifle, some fairly pricey gear, and wear nice camo. Does that mean all of my bucks are high fence? We’ve got five strands of barbwire around our place if that counts.
Posted By: Thefofive

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/16/19 03:30 PM

Tell me again the pride I should feel when I kill a pen-raised "trophy" buck? Where the smell of a human means an apple or a pear to eat?

Keith Warren and his Deer and Wildlife Stories on YouTube. GMAB! He should call it Deer and Tamelife Stories.

I know it's legal but, IMO, and it's my opinion as well as most, whitetail deer were not meant to be commercialized like cows.

I'd rather shoot a free-range 4 yr old 120" in the swamps than a 200" pen-raised.
Posted By: rulebreaker

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/16/19 03:34 PM

Originally Posted by Coosa1
Originally Posted by rulebreaker
Originally Posted by rulebreaker
No comment.


My statement from 1/26/19. ^^^^

Anytime you see a HUGE buck and a $3K gun and the hunter wearing $1K worth clothing and gear, you can just about guarantee that it's a 'high fence' kill.


I carry a $2k+ rifle, some fairly pricey gear, and wear nice camo. Does that mean all of my bucks are high fence? We’ve got five strands of barbwire around our place if that counts.


I don't know. Show us some HUGE buck pics and I'll give you my opinion.
Posted By: Thefofive

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/16/19 03:45 PM

I just watched a Primos video. It takes those guys MANY hours of filming to capture a decent kill. I watched one of the Primos guys bow hunting the swamps off the MS River. They shot a decent mature buck and I loved watching it! That's hunting. That's The Truth and it's Free-Range deer.
Posted By: Bamabucks14

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/16/19 04:35 PM

Originally Posted by rulebreaker
Originally Posted by Coosa1
Originally Posted by rulebreaker
Originally Posted by rulebreaker
No comment.


My statement from 1/26/19. ^^^^

Anytime you see a HUGE buck and a $3K gun and the hunter wearing $1K worth clothing and gear, you can just about guarantee that it's a 'high fence' kill.


I carry a $2k+ rifle, some fairly pricey gear, and wear nice camo. Does that mean all of my bucks are high fence? We’ve got five strands of barbwire around our place if that counts.


I don't know. Show us some HUGE buck pics and I'll give you my opinion.

Shots fired!
Posted By: leroycnbucks

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/16/19 05:39 PM

Us hunters are our own worst enemy.
Posted By: Coosa1

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/16/19 05:41 PM

Originally Posted by rulebreaker


I don't know. Show us some HUGE buck pics and I'll give you my opinion.


I missed the part where it said HUGE, best I can get are BIG bucks laugh
Posted By: willdo22

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/16/19 07:10 PM

Originally Posted by leroycnbucks
Us hunters are our own worst enemy.


X2
Posted By: MarksOutdoors

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/16/19 08:01 PM

Originally Posted by Coosa1
Originally Posted by rulebreaker
Originally Posted by rulebreaker
No comment.


My statement from 1/26/19. ^^^^

Anytime you see a HUGE buck and a $3K gun and the hunter wearing $1K worth clothing and gear, you can just about guarantee that it's a 'high fence' kill.


I carry a $2k+ rifle, some fairly pricey gear, and wear nice camo. Does that mean all of my bucks are high fence? We’ve got five strands of barbwire around our place if that counts.

How many sponsors you got? wink
Posted By: Sasquatch Lives

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/17/19 12:48 AM

High fence hunters don't have the skills to get it done fair chase. That's why.
Posted By: fourfive45

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/17/19 02:12 AM

I’ve already formed second opinions on those who thought this deer was free range.
Posted By: jb20

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/17/19 03:07 AM

Originally Posted by fourfive45
I’ve already formed second opinions on those who thought this deer was free range.

U know what opinions r like? smile
Posted By: BhamFred

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/17/19 03:09 AM

Originally Posted by fourfive45
I’ve already formed second opinions on those who thought this deer was free range.


why would YOU think it wasn't? Too big?
Posted By: AU338MAG

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/17/19 01:10 PM

Originally Posted by rulebreaker
Originally Posted by rulebreaker
No comment.


My statement from 1/26/19. ^^^^

Anytime you see a HUGE buck and a $3K gun and the hunter wearing $1K worth clothing and gear, you can just about guarantee that it's a 'high fence' kill.

Some of my guns are worth 3K or more, but have not been used in a high fence...
Posted By: Halfrack

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/17/19 03:03 PM

Originally Posted by fourfive45
I’ve already formed second opinions on those who thought this deer was free range.


I guess you can tell free range from high fence or you don't think deer get that big in Bama or Lowndes county? I M curious as to how you can tell.
Posted By: dirkdaddy

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/17/19 05:51 PM

Originally Posted by Halfrack
Originally Posted by fourfive45
I’ve already formed second opinions on those who thought this deer was free range.


I guess you can tell free range from high fence or you don't think deer get that big in Bama or Lowndes county? I M curious as to how you can tell.
He could tell it wasn't free range because in all his years hunting he's never seen or come close to one even within 70 inches of that deer.
Posted By: therealhojo

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/17/19 08:12 PM

Originally Posted by Coosa1
Originally Posted by rulebreaker
Originally Posted by rulebreaker
No comment.


My statement from 1/26/19. ^^^^

Anytime you see a HUGE buck and a $3K gun and the hunter wearing $1K worth clothing and gear, you can just about guarantee that it's a 'high fence' kill.


I carry a $2k+ rifle, some fairly pricey gear, and wear nice camo. Does that mean all of my bucks are high fence? We’ve got five strands of barbwire around our place if that counts.


5 isn't high, 6 is.
Posted By: FurFlyin

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/17/19 08:36 PM

What an absolute ass. I've seen that guy or someone that looks an aweful lot like him somewhere before.
Posted By: ALclearcut

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/18/19 01:59 PM

Originally Posted by abolt300
Here's an honest question. Why would someone claim that a deer that was killed in an enclosure on a pay hunt as being a free-range deer?? Most of those bucks are cataloged with pics on them on the high fence's website for advertising. I mean it is just stupid. Word will get out. Is a day of internet fame worth losing your reputation for life? I just do not understand this mentality and it seems to be a common occurrence that replays itself on here year after year.


Most of these types aren't even hunters, which is why they are dumb enough to think their 6,000 dollar deer actually is a new record. They haven't hunted long enough to even understand the difference in free range v. breeder facility. And the guides at these high fences really put the sales pitch to them, talking about what an awesome hunter they are, how that buck has been the hardest to hunt, and how it's the biggest deer they have ever seen killed anywhere in that area. The guy's rifle looks brand new and his name brand high dollar hunting clothes look brand new. I guarantee you the high fence guides put such a show on for him that he legitimately believed he had killed the county record and sent it off to the record books. You think the high fence guide is going to turn around and tell him his $6,000 buck is ineligible for the record book since it is nothing more than livestock?
Posted By: Coosa1

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/18/19 02:04 PM

Originally Posted by MarksOutdoors
Originally Posted by Coosa1


I carry a $2k+ rifle, some fairly pricey gear, and wear nice camo. Does that mean all of my bucks are high fence? We’ve got five strands of barbwire around our place if that counts.

How many sponsors you got?


Not a single one. I just worked at a gun store and got really good discounts during the time of my life when I also had very few bills. wink
Posted By: fourfive45

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/18/19 10:33 PM

Originally Posted by dirkdaddy
Originally Posted by Halfrack
Originally Posted by fourfive45
I’ve already formed second opinions on those who thought this deer was free range.


I guess you can tell free range from high fence or you don't think deer get that big in Bama or Lowndes county? I M curious as to how you can tell.
He could tell it wasn't free range because in all his years hunting he's never seen or come close to one even within 70 inches of that deer.


The cut in the ear is suspect that it had a tag. That’s clue number one. Now I’m not saying a deer can’t cut it’s ear in a natural way, it’s just a hint that deer a tag. I’ve hunted Lowndes my whole life. Deer like that were taken regularly in the 80s when everyone was planting soybeans. I just haven’t seen many huge deer like that since. The amount of high fence operations have is staggering in Lowndes.

I just came to the conclusion it was a high fence deer based on that. We all have external factors that affect our opinions and those were mine. I could care less is someone shot a deer in high fence or not. Frankly, I could give 2 chits about deer hunting. I like to go watch the deer, take my kids, and eat venison. And I can tell you, I’ve seen bigger deer than that on hoof in Aransas from a duck hole. I just thought it was funny all you guys getting butthurt over someone else’s opinion because it’s different than yours.
Posted By: jb20

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/18/19 10:55 PM

Originally Posted by fourfive45
Originally Posted by dirkdaddy
Originally Posted by Halfrack
Originally Posted by fourfive45
I’ve already formed second opinions on those who thought this deer was free range.


I guess you can tell free range from high fence or you don't think deer get that big in Bama or Lowndes county? I M curious as to how you can tell.
He could tell it wasn't free range because in all his years hunting he's never seen or come close to one even within 70 inches of that deer.


The cut in the ear is suspect that it had a tag. That’s clue number one. Now I’m not saying a deer can’t cut it’s ear in a natural way, it’s just a hint that deer a tag. I’ve hunted Lowndes my whole life. Deer like that were taken regularly in the 80s when everyone was planting soybeans. I just haven’t seen many huge deer like that since. The amount of high fence operations have is staggering in Lowndes.

I just came to the conclusion it was a high fence deer based on that. We all have external factors that affect our opinions and those were mine. I could care less is someone shot a deer in high fence or not. Frankly, I could give 2 chits about deer hunting. I like to go watch the deer, take my kids, and eat venison. And I can tell you, I’ve seen bigger deer than that on hoof in Aransas from a duck hole. I just thought it was funny all you guys getting butthurt over someone else’s opinion because it’s different than yours.

Not butthurt u said u formed opinions of people on this site that thought it was free range...what kinda opinion did u form for the less intelligent people on here
Posted By: jwalker77

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/18/19 11:24 PM

The buck I killed saturday before season ended had an ear cut in two places, almost tore off. My question is if he was gona go pay to kill a deer and lie about it, why didnt he kill a big one? Pen deer these days go over 200inches on their first rack.
Posted By: marshmud991

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/19/19 05:07 AM

Pen deer don't interest me at all. Had a guy at the camp this season bragging about a 140ish 10 pt he killed in Texas. O asked if it was free range. He said " well it's a high fence operation but it's like 10k acres". I just change the subject and the guy got all butt hurt because we didn't want to hear about his big deer. To each their own.
Posted By: UncleHuck

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/19/19 11:55 AM


I hunt multiple properties in Texas, some free range, some not. I can tell you from personal experience that there is very little difference, if any at all, in hunting free range deer and hunting high fence once you get over about 1800 acres inside the fence, and once you pass 3000 acres, any perceived difference is gone.

We have seen a buck chased by a coyote jump a high fence. I will also add that there are very few places in South Texas brush country and the Hill Country that you could find 10,000 acres without a high fence impacting it in some way. I hunt a 2500 acre low fence place where the neighbors high fenced 2 full sides, and a 5500 acre low fence parcel with one full side an part of a second high fence. It's really almost everywhere.

You may agree or disagree, but the small fence operations, less than 400 acres, really aren't hunting. There is no way to sustain the population. Once you get to the big units, 2500+ acres, especially the ones with no supplemental breeding, the deer are as wild as they are anywhere I have hunted in Alabama.
Posted By: marshmud991

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/19/19 12:20 PM

UncleHuck, I understand what you are saying and if you enjoy hunting in a fence more power to ya. It just doesn't interest me at all. I'm not saying that is I was invited to hunt in a large enclosure that I wouldn't go, I'm saying I wouldn't go around showing off and bragging about a deer that had been raised in a "pen" no matter the size. I know it's big business in Texas and I'm happy for them but it's just not for me. But I'm not going to put a person down for hunting in a fence, just don't come bragging to me about a deer that was killed in it.
Posted By: Thefofive

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/19/19 01:48 PM

Regarding cut ears of mature bucks... if you kill a 4+ yr old buck, it would be unusual for him not to have one or both ears cut. I have seen some older mature bucks that have been killed that hung out by themselves (not a bachelor group) nor chased does and didn't lose their velvet until late. They've either had one testicle or no testicles and perfect ears, which makes sense about the bucks' chosen lifestyle. Low T!!

Anyway, I do believe that deer in a large enough enclosure are very hard to hunt. But these purchased bucks that are intended to be shot and are purchased TO BE SHOT and they just hang out and aimlessly mill about looking for an apple, is nothing to brag about. I would not do it.
Posted By: Sasquatch Lives

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/19/19 01:51 PM

Originally Posted by marshmud991
Pen deer don't interest me at all. Had a guy at the camp this season bragging about a 140ish 10 pt he killed in Texas. O asked if it was free range. He said " well it's a high fence operation but it's like 10k acres". I just change the subject and the guy got all butt hurt because we didn't want to hear about his big deer. To each their own.

A 140 10 pt. in Texas ain't nothing special. A 140 10 pt. high fence buck ain't worth even talking about. You can't trust a man who would shoot a fenced in animal anyway.
Posted By: Halfrack

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/19/19 04:36 PM

Originally Posted by fourfive45
Originally Posted by dirkdaddy
Originally Posted by Halfrack
Originally Posted by fourfive45
I’ve already formed second opinions on those who thought this deer was free range.


I guess you can tell free range from high fence or you don't think deer get that big in Bama or Lowndes county? I M curious as to how you can tell.
He could tell it wasn't free range because in all his years hunting he's never seen or come close to one even within 70 inches of that deer.


The cut in the ear is suspect that it had a tag. That’s clue number one. Now I’m not saying a deer can’t cut it’s ear in a natural way, it’s just a hint that deer a tag. I’ve hunted Lowndes my whole life. Deer like that were taken regularly in the 80s when everyone was planting soybeans. I just haven’t seen many huge deer like that since. The amount of high fence operations have is staggering in Lowndes.

I just came to the conclusion it was a high fence deer based on that. We all have external factors that affect our opinions and those were mine. I could care less is someone shot a deer in high fence or not. Frankly, I could give 2 chits about deer hunting. I like to go watch the deer, take my kids, and eat venison. And I can tell you, I’ve seen bigger deer than that on hoof in Aransas from a duck hole. I just thought it was funny all you guys getting butthurt over someone else’s opinion because it’s different than yours.


I'm not butthurt either but your cut ear theory is a bunch of crap. I believe that every mature buck I've ever killed has had a cut or torn ear or ears I guess they were all escaped pen deer who removed the tags themselves.
Posted By: zgobbler5

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 02/20/19 11:37 PM

What does John Travis have to say about all this?
Posted By: crenshawco

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/24/19 02:24 PM

Looks like the place this deer came off of is for sale now.

https://jonkohler.com/property/alabama/fort-deposit-outfitters/fort-deposit-outfitters-galleries/
Posted By: AU338MAG

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/24/19 02:53 PM

Originally Posted by crenshawco

Been on the market for a while now.

All you gotta do is stroke a check...
Posted By: Avengedsevenfold

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/24/19 04:11 PM

Originally Posted by Sasquatch Lives

You can't trust a man who would shoot a fenced in animal anyway.


That might be taking it a little far..
Posted By: eskimo270

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/24/19 04:25 PM

It would be cool if skinny would take the aldeer proceeds and buy that place and let us hunt it
Posted By: Coosa1

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/24/19 06:20 PM

Originally Posted by eskimo270
It would be cool if skinny would take the aldeer proceeds and buy that place and let us hunt it


An ALDEER hunting club would be an absolute chit show between the "Let em grow" guys and the spike shooters and between the master hunters and master baiters.
Posted By: BhamFred

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/24/19 06:46 PM

there is no difference in a 10,000 acre managed high fence and a 10,000 acre managed no fence place as far as hunting is concerned. Anybody that says different is full of chitt.
Posted By: wew3006

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/24/19 07:24 PM

Originally Posted by AU338MAG
Originally Posted by rulebreaker
Originally Posted by rulebreaker
No comment.


My statement from 1/26/19. ^^^^

Anytime you see a HUGE buck and a $3K gun and the hunter wearing $1K worth clothing and gear, you can just about guarantee that it's a 'high fence' kill.

Some of my guns are worth 3K or more, but have not been used in a high fence...


Same here; maybe why I can't afford a high fence hunt; if I wanted to, which I don't
Posted By: UncleHuck

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/24/19 08:36 PM


I am always amazed at the folks here who have never been on a high fence ranch at all, much less on a hunt, who seem to know all about them.
Posted By: Gobl4me

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/25/19 12:11 PM

I've never been in a high fence. We have a few thousand acres we run cattle on. So I understand the concept
Posted By: CarbonClimber1

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/27/19 12:56 AM

Originally Posted by BhamFred
there is no difference in a 10,000 acre managed high fence and a 10,000 acre managed no fence place as far as hunting is concerned. Anybody that says different is full of chitt.

Dilly dilly
Posted By: Fldoghunter

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/27/19 03:23 PM

The way so many folks are worried about what others are shooting and how their neighbors might shoot "their" deer, I'd be surprised if high fence hunting doesn't become more popular than it already is.
Posted By: AU338MAG

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/27/19 05:01 PM

Originally Posted by Fldoghunter
The way so many folks are worried about what others are shooting and how their neighbors might shoot "their" deer, I'd be surprised if high fence hunting doesn't become more popular than it already is.

There are hundreds of high fence operations in Alabama.
Posted By: Goatkiller

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/28/19 06:35 PM

I have absolutely no issues with a high fence operation. I think you will see more and more of them in the future, in particular in Alabama, simply because if you want to manage your deer you can't otherwise. The season and bag limits are too liberal. The required amount of real estate you would need in order to manage your deer under our current system is out of most rich people's price range and it's too much work. In particular if they just want to show up and hunt. They spend that money on a smaller tract, less maintenance and more money to move some good deer inside the fence, and pay a couple hands to work it.

That being said... I don't care how many acres and how tall the fence is.... you are shooting livestock at that point. I know someone that's got a couple thousand fenced and you pull up to the gate and many times there are deer standing on the other side. You punch in the key code. The gate opens and you drive on in. Deer still standing there. I usually stop the truck and let the gate close just behind me because I'm afraid one is going to run out and then I'm going to be the guy who let the deer run out and never hear the end of it.... "Remember that time ____ let the big shooter buck run out the front gate.... blah, blah, blah."

High fence operations are great for a few different groups of hunters: 1) The guy that can't grow anything bigger than a basket rack because his neighbors shoot everything they see - 2) A guy like Luke Bryan and 3) Everyone else that has no freaking clue how to hunt deer without the use of a food plot and/or feeder (most of you who are reading this).
Posted By: jlbuc10

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/28/19 06:57 PM

Originally Posted by CarbonClimber1
Originally Posted by BhamFred
there is no difference in a 10,000 acre managed high fence and a 10,000 acre managed no fence place as far as hunting is concerned. Anybody that says different is full of chitt.

Dilly dilly

Just for discussion. 10,000 acres is 15.6 square miles. For arguments sake let’s say it’s a 4mile by 4 mile square. Is it not unheard of for bucks in the rut to travel longer distances than 4 miles to find a doe? Would a fence not make a significant difference on bucks that you’ve fed and managed not leaving during the rut and being shot by neighbors?
Posted By: Clem

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/28/19 08:47 PM

Originally Posted by AU338MAG
Originally Posted by Fldoghunter
The way so many folks are worried about what others are shooting and how their neighbors might shoot "their" deer, I'd be surprised if high fence hunting doesn't become more popular than it already is.

There are hundreds of high fence operations in Alabama.


And have been for years. These big pens are nothing new.
Posted By: blumsden

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/29/19 11:42 AM

Hell, i'm thinking about fencing in my place. If for no other reason, to keep these damn free ranging dogs that these dumbasses say they love, but wont keep them on their property.
Posted By: UncleHuck

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/29/19 11:46 AM


I would love to have 3-5000 acres high fence somewhere in Alabama just to see what could grow here with native genetics.
Posted By: Remington270

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/29/19 12:20 PM

Originally Posted by BhamFred
there is no difference in a 10,000 acre managed high fence and a 10,000 acre managed no fence place as far as hunting is concerned. Anybody that says different is full of chitt.


Maybe not, but the vast majority of fenced in properties are much smaller than 10,000 contiguous acres. I've hunted a 1,600 acre property that was a petting zoo. Never seen that in the wild...
Posted By: BhamFred

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/29/19 12:36 PM

only way deer on 1600 acres were tame was they were bottle raised in small pens and released on the 1600.
Posted By: lectrode

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/29/19 01:54 PM

Originally Posted by UncleHuck

I would love to have 3-5000 acres high fence somewhere in Alabama just to see what could grow here with native genetics.

My opinion is you would be very dissapointed
Posted By: Goatkiller

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/29/19 02:07 PM

You might grow some decent 8 pointers. I think Alabama deer have a lot more potential than we give them credit for but nothing like what you would want if you went to the expense to high fence a place.


1600 acres ain't crap. I've seen cow pastures that were 2 squares with no cross fence. I could run around that for my morning workout. It's a big pen but it's still a pen at that size. Having been on several places I would say you need 3,000+ before the deer are skittish of human scent scared of the truck and/or run from humans snorting and carrying on. Minimum.

I'm not knocking it there are just not many operations that big... and why I have no interest in hunting on a smaller one.


Posted By: AU338MAG

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/29/19 02:25 PM

I would say the vast majority of the high fenced areas I've seen in Alabama are 300-600 acres. Some as small as 40 acres slap and a few that were over a 1000 acres.
Posted By: Coosa1

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/29/19 03:17 PM

Originally Posted by lectrode
Originally Posted by UncleHuck

I would love to have 3-5000 acres high fence somewhere in Alabama just to see what could grow here with native genetics.

My opinion is you would be very dissapointed


I disagree. I mean yeah you wouldn't get the 200+" freaks that you see advertised on the fenced hunts. But a lot of Alabama deer could be pretty nice if they weren't gunned down as 2 year olds and had access to decent nutrition.
Posted By: Remington270

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/29/19 03:19 PM

Originally Posted by AU338MAG
I would say the vast majority of the high fenced areas I've seen in Alabama are 300-600 acres. Some as small as 40 acres slap and a few that were over a 1000 acres.


You're right.
Posted By: HippieKiller

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/29/19 03:57 PM

Southern Falls (Peavy's place) is a good example of native AL deer fenced in and allowed to grow. They kill some really nice deer, but nothing I've seen would I call "monsters."
Posted By: CarbonClimber1

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/29/19 04:37 PM

Theys a difference between deer breeders high fence operation and extreme wildlife and or trophy management...most folks cant afford the fence much less the land to put it around...if you could afford 10k acres...and a high fence around it...and you could afford to control most all property and wildlife management aspects to keep the land in pristine condition...you could slowly control invasive species, reestablish native grasses, have an effective burn rotation with well maintained fire breaks...i mean,..why not? Grid the property off and really focus and take time to improve the animals social structure and give them what they need to flourish...and not to mention serious high volume predator control...and attempt to stand a decent chance of keepin douche bags from raping and pillaging land illegally. Yes you could do all this without a fence but after you spent all that time and money...why would you want to throw it all away so your redkneck neighbor billy joe bob shoot the first spike i see guy...SHOOTS THE FIRST SPIKE HE SEES!!....im poh tho...so my argument is worthless....i will say that ive seent the above work extremely well in texas...and by george them deer was wild down there...they just really like corn....you better have some deep pockets tho..and a few millyuns want cut it...you gon need lotsa millyuns..dilly dilly laugh
Posted By: AU338MAG

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/29/19 05:02 PM

Originally Posted by CarbonClimber1
Theys a difference between deer breeders high fence operation and extreme wildlife and or trophy management...most folks cant afford the fence much less the land to put it around...if you could afford 10k acres...and a high fence around it...and you could afford to control most all property and wildlife management aspects to keep the land in pristine condition...you could slowly control invasive species, reestablish native grasses, have an effective burn rotation with well maintained fire breaks...i mean,..why not? Grid the property off and really focus and take time to improve the animals social structure and give them what they need to flourish...and not to mention serious high volume predator control...and attempt to stand a decent chance of keepin douche bags from raping and pillaging land illegally. Yes you could do all this without a fence but after you spent all that time and money...why would you want to throw it all away so your redkneck neighbor billy joe bob shoot the first spike i see guy...SHOOTS THE FIRST SPIKE HE SEES!!....im poh tho...so my argument is worthless....i will say that ive seent the above work extremely well in texas...and by george them deer was wild down there...they just really like corn....you better have some deep pockets tho..and a few millyuns want cut it...you gon need lotsa millyuns..dilly dilly laugh

I read an article years ago about Texas deer management. One of the owners said their operating costs were $75-85 per acre. This was several years ago...
Posted By: UncleHuck

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/29/19 06:01 PM


I get to hunt a 5000 acre low fence place near Laredo and a 2700 acre high fence near Freer. Neither is a guarantee, but I get an invite most years to one or the other.

Neither have stocked deer, just supplemental protein and corn for the natives.

I have not seen any variance in the behavior of the deer between the high and low fence places. If you make noise, they haul boogie away from you, and you hunt with the blind windows closed if temps will allow. Both try to have the blinds at least 150 yards from the feeder pen, further if possible.
Posted By: CarbonClimber1

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/29/19 08:18 PM

Originally Posted by AU338MAG
Originally Posted by CarbonClimber1
Theys a difference between deer breeders high fence operation and extreme wildlife and or trophy management...most folks cant afford the fence much less the land to put it around...if you could afford 10k acres...and a high fence around it...and you could afford to control most all property and wildlife management aspects to keep the land in pristine condition...you could slowly control invasive species, reestablish native grasses, have an effective burn rotation with well maintained fire breaks...i mean,..why not? Grid the property off and really focus and take time to improve the animals social structure and give them what they need to flourish...and not to mention serious high volume predator control...and attempt to stand a decent chance of keepin douche bags from raping and pillaging land illegally. Yes you could do all this without a fence but after you spent all that time and money...why would you want to throw it all away so your redkneck neighbor billy joe bob shoot the first spike i see guy...SHOOTS THE FIRST SPIKE HE SEES!!....im poh tho...so my argument is worthless....i will say that ive seent the above work extremely well in texas...and by george them deer was wild down there...they just really like corn....you better have some deep pockets tho..and a few millyuns want cut it...you gon need lotsa millyuns..dilly dilly laugh

I read an article years ago about Texas deer management. One of the owners said their operating costs were $75-85 per acre. This was several years ago...
that number would be low for most places now i think...its rediculous what some people are willing to pay for pine goats an them squigly things comin outah their head...id personally rather live like a pirate in the carribean an catch yahoos an melrlins
grin
Posted By: hunterbuck

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/29/19 10:45 PM

I hunted a lot in the midwest and Canada earlier in my life, and have some really big bucks on the wall as a result. I now have zero interest in doing it anymore.

I get a lot more satisfaction in killing good bucks off of and managing my own property, or our club's property...something I had a hand in.
Posted By: bama1971

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/30/19 12:04 AM

Originally Posted by Coosa1
Originally Posted by lectrode
Originally Posted by UncleHuck

I would love to have 3-5000 acres high fence somewhere in Alabama just to see what could grow here with native genetics.

My opinion is you would be very dissapointed


I disagree. I mean yeah you wouldn't get the 200+" freaks that you see advertised on the fenced hunts. But a lot of Alabama deer could be pretty nice if they weren't gunned down as 2 year olds and had access to decent nutrition.


Agree with your disagreement, a lot of no fence large acreage places kill 150”+ deer every year, just from low pressure and selective shooting
Posted By: lectrode

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/30/19 01:38 AM

Of course there are going to be a few deer that would be decent, thats not really what I meant. We have some pretty decent deer on our lease with very little pressure but have a the few that are killed that barely make our minimum but are aged at 4 to 5 years old. I guess it would be interesting if the money were no issue. If I had that kind of money I would buy a couple of farms in Kansas and Iowa though.
Posted By: WmHunter

Re: Lowndes County Smasher!!!! - 05/30/19 06:26 PM

Originally Posted by bama1971
Originally Posted by Coosa1
Originally Posted by lectrode
Originally Posted by UncleHuck

I would love to have 3-5000 acres high fence somewhere in Alabama just to see what could grow here with native genetics.

My opinion is you would be very dissapointed


I disagree. I mean yeah you wouldn't get the 200+" freaks that you see advertised on the fenced hunts. But a lot of Alabama deer could be pretty nice if they weren't gunned down as 2 year olds and had access to decent nutrition.


Agree with your disagreement, a lot of no fence large acreage places kill 150”+ deer every year, just from low pressure and selective shooting



This is why I have my 5000 acres high fenced in.
Killed off half the native deer then imported 100 deer from Iowa, 100 from Illinois, 100 from Kansas and 100 from Alberta.
© 2024 ALDEER.COM