I'm sure y'all are telling the truth, but I've NEVER hunted a fresh cut nor one that is still being logged. Yes, I've heard all the crazy stories, but I think that's all they are--crazy stories, not the norm. Y'all being serious when you say you prefer a fresh dirt cutover over one about belt-high in regrowth?? I mean, if that's all I had on my place I'd give it a shot, but if there's a nasty briar infested cutover vs a new one, uuuhhhh I ain't hunting that new one.
One of my two or three best lifelong friends owns one of the biggest logging operations in this part of the state, and he's told me lots of stories of deer eating treetops while the equipment is running, etc. But he don't hunt fresh cuts. We've hunted together for 40 years since childhood and not once have we hunted a fresh cutover. He would know.
All I know is our club has had several areas cut during the season. On one 40 acre cut, as soon as they moved out, we set up a tripod. The first time it was hunted, there were over 20 deer seen, including a shooter buck. The next day, another shooter was seen but the gun misfired (didn't fire) and a lot of deer were seen. One member that we didn't really like and didn't tell, happened to be driving by and saw a doe standing in it. He hunted it for several days, killed some does, and it went cold.
I hunted another several hundred acre cut over (cut in the summer and it was down to the dirt) and would see deer in it nearly every time. The deer didn't linger, but would pass though. I killed a 121" 8 pt on the trail of a doe during the rut at 200 yards. I saw other shooters. The next year, it was nearly too tall to hunt because they didn't spray or re-plant. Hunt them while you can!!!